Messageboard

About RadChad from United States: Mariah is my favorite singer of all time.

Beautiful as a whole (37,784) by RadChad from United States Okay, the song is one of those songs that gets better and better with each listen, having said that I think it's a good infectious tune and will be a huge summer hit. As far as the video goes: I'll start with the good moments. She got her killer bod back, loved the silhouette poses she did, her energy was great (beats her laying down in every video). I just wish MC would've toned down the outfits just a wee bit, because it distracts from the song and haters wil have a field day with the way she's dressed. Also, all the leg and butt shots just looks a bit too contrived, the editor should found a more subtle/creative way to highlight MC's rocking body. The skirt dance was cute, but she shouldn't have raised it so high . You all know I love MC like no other, but in a nutshell the video could be a lot better (I wish I could've directed it). I just hope she doesn't follow this pattern with the rest of her videos, because her voice and natural beauty should be highlighted this era. I hope she comes to realize this and start taking the less is more approach (image wise), because that's where she really shines the brightest. (Friday 10 May 2013; 15:39)

Final Idol weigh in (37,687) by RadChad from United States Laura Saltman said it perfectly. Nicki isn't a bad judge, she just wasn't needed. The show would've worked perfectly with just Mariah, Keith, and Randy, they all have good spirits about them. For me Nicki just throws off the chemistry on the panel, if they wanted her on there they should've just brought her on next season as the only female judge. The producers were being messy by adding Nicki to the panel after publicily making it known that Mariah wasn't happy about it. If J.Lo was able to get the courtesy of being the only female judge, then Mariah should've gotten the same courtesy. So all the bad drama and ratings is their fault and it serves them right that their plan to create drama for ratings backfired big time. Also I don't think the public really care about Mariah being "too nice" or whatever, it's definitely not why the ratings are down, the public just want to see great contestants and the judges having great chemistry and occasional fun, friendly banter. Not real drama and negativity. Having said all that, I can't wait for Mariah to move on from this whole mess and let the music trump the negavity thrown her way. Success is the sweetest revenge. (Saturday 4 May 2013; 20:52)

Ribbon (37,605) by RadChad from United States I agree, I'm not too thrilled about her lead single being a duet. Miguel is a pretty cool artist, but I'm not sure if I even like the idea of him on the same track with MC (I guess an album track would be fine or second single). Also how would she promote/perform the song affectively without him (I'm sure Miguel won't show up to all her performances and via video would be annoying/awkward IMO). I can go on and on. Now if he just produced the song for her then that'll be better. I just hope it doesn't turn into a train wreck or come across as desperate to be current. Because you know that she's not the "desperate type" (I had too ). All I need is organically great music and vocals and I'll be satisfied, but at the end of it all I just hope she makes the right move and release the right material. (Wednesday 24 April 2013; 3:50)

MC on AI this week (37,592) by RadChad from United States I just want to say I think MC was awesome on AI this week. I don't know about other people, but the show just made me love her even more (and I didn't think that was possible ). Getting to see her on tv every week has been a dream come true for me. (Saturday 20 April 2013; 18:48)

Re: Judging on AI (37,546) by RadChad from United States Ok, so I heard the part about her being accused of being "too nice"(which everyone agreed on), but didn't catch the part about her "not providing enough helpful criticism" (not saying it wasn't said). But, if that was said, then I still disagree. Now, it's all subjective and everyone has a right to their own opinion, and having said that I feel vindicated in mine as well. (Friday 12 April 2013; 18:31)

Carla/ AI (37,537) by RadChad from United States I'll have to give it a listen, Butterfly is my second favorite MC song of all time next to (Love Takes Time). In reference to AI. Mariah has given Lazaro, Paul Jolly, and others very useful advise. She's told Lazaros several times that he sings a half step too low, she told Paul Jolly to put the same amount of passion in his lower register as he does his upper register. They just didn't listen, I don't understand what else people could expect her to do. As far as how much she's getting paid, she doing just as good as anyone else on the show as far as I'm concerned. So well deserved Mariah. For me the real problem of the show is that four judges is just too much. After the third person speaks, it starts seeming like beating a dead horse. I believe the show would've been more enjoyable with just three judges. AI tried to over do it this year and it backfired. (Thursday 11 April 2013; 2:39)

Carla (37,529) by RadChad from United States I totally agree with you. I don't know why people expect Mariah to go in and rip the contestants apart on Idol. The thing is, not only is Mariah a very sensitive caring person (that's considerate of other people's feeling), but also she can empathize with having an off performance or two, so she gives constructive critism in the nicest way possible. Big deal. This just proves that whatever she does ppl will have an issue with it. If she went in on the contestants, people would be saying she's a "b!tch" or "she can't sing like she use to herself", when she nice she's too "soft and boring". I'm sure Mariah has had personal constructive conversations with the contestants about their voice off camera because she always say "we've talked about this" when critiquing, so I see it as just there to help and mentor. Besides, you don't need everybody on the panel going in on you, there's enough of that. So I'm all for MC being on team nice. On another note, I also hope she jumps the sinking ship by next season. (Wednesday 10 April 2013; 16:58)

Licia (37,495) by RadChad from United States Let me clarify, I'm not condoning threats or violence against her (that is taking too far). However she does deserve reproach/backlash for her negative comments IMO. (Wednesday 27 March 2013; 14:07)

Re: Sam (37,487) by RadChad from United States Thanks Sam. It's always great to be on the same page with a fellow lamb. (Tuesday 26 March 2013; 19:04)

Paying the price (37,484) by RadChad from United States I think Kelly got what she deserved. Even if she wasn't speaking about Mariah in particular, it was still very shady of her to tweet those things. Like the saying goes, you get what you give. Personally I believe she was referring to Mariah. Now, why would she go there about a woman that practically put her on the map and changed her life forever? I would never understand. Having said that, celebrities need to stop acting as if twitter is their living room, their followers are close family members/confidants, and whatever they tweet won't be on display for the world to see. Because once you put a statement like that out there to the world, then you open yourself up for whatever opinions people have on it. (Tuesday 26 March 2013; 6:16)

Mariah titles (37,447) by RadChad from United States I'm not sure how much of it is her or her teams fault regarding her being announced as the "most this" and the "best selling that", but I would agree that maybe it's a constant reminder to the powers that be that, "we can't let this woman eclipse the Beatles, she already got King Elvis", having said that I could agree with the "stealthy" approach mentioned. We must remember Mariah has had her underdog moments in the industry from being snubbed by the Grammies for years, crucified and written off for Glitter, to being dragged through the mud over her breakdown. So I'm sure there's people out there that feels some kind of way about her success being slapped across their faces (which I love btw ). However, by her being the diva everyone loves to hate on and write off, the stealthy approach is the way to go (*whispers* at least until she breaks the Beatles record. Shhh! *looks over shoulder*). (Wednesday 20 March 2013; 1:35)

Musical success (37,427) by RadChad from United States I agree with everyone saying we need to just enjoy her music and be thankful for her legacy and longevity. However, in my opinion, Mariah's lack of success with her lastest two singles is due to radio is not playing her songs like they use to. Ever since she last hit number 1 with TMB, it seems that radio stopped playing her as much. A few thoughts that came across my mind were: is it that the industry doesn't want her to break the Beatles record so they boycotted her music, or is it the fact that's she in her early forties now? Who really knows? The only way for Mariah to beat these odds is to have a well promoted undeniable hit song. Then the stations would have no excuse not to play it. I'm just looking forward to great material. I truly believe that if she has the right material and promotion, her new era could be a huge comeback which would be beyond legendary for her career. (Monday 18 March 2013; 22:38)

Easily influenced by the media (37,389) by RadChad from United States Wow, it's amazing how some of you guys allow yourselves to be spoon fed biased hypocrisy from the media and are quick to jump on the negative bandwagon regarding MC. How in the world the hater that wrote that tacky article and some of you can muster up the audacity to come down on MC for jokingly using the phrase "I can't even know what to say" and then praise Nicki Minaj when she has made countless ridiculous statement through the entire season. SMH. Some of you Mariah fans, I tell you. (Wednesday 13 March 2013; 0:47)

Who cares? (37,381) by RadChad from United States Though I've enjoyed Mariah on Idol (and think she gives great feedback), I could care less about her being considered the best tv judge ever. All I really care about is her taking care of that amazing voice, making great music, and her happiness (of course). People will never give this woman the credit she truly deserves anyway. She has always been the underdog. So I've just learned to be satisfied with knowing that she gives it her all and keeps going despite the adversity she faces. As far as the current state of her music career, much can be speculated about why it's not as stellar as it once was. However, I still feel the best from is yet to come and she will have another huge comeback. (Tuesday 12 March 2013; 13:57)

Congrats to a queen (37,324) by RadChad from United States I hope once the video premieres it flies up the Hot 100. On a side note, MC has been looking strikingly beautiful on Idol these past couple weeks and I'm loving her judging style as well. I'm happy we finally get to see what the panel is really like without all the extra editing. (Friday 1 March 2013; 19:11)

Sounding like Rihanna (37,282) by RadChad from United States I agree with Zachary. Honestly, Rihanna never came to my mind at all when I first heard the full song. The only similarity I hear is the beat sounding like Diamonds' half brother (which is the only thing I could criticize about it) but vocally she's in great shape and sounds nothing like Rihanna IMO. I think you all are associating her vocals with Rihanna's because she's using her lower register so strongly in the verses, but you have remember two things. 1. Mariah's been using that register for years, think Melt Away, Baby Doll, Petals. And 2. Mariah is Rihanna's biggest influence, so if anything Rihanna pick up a few things from Mariah's sound and incorporated it into her sound. But all that's besides the point as far as I'm concerned. Mariah still sounds like Mariah to me. (Friday 22 February 2013; 21:59)

Almost Home (37,238) by RadChad from United States The song is cool, fitting for the Disney production. The vocals are definitely back. I mean, I really haven't heard her mid voice this way in years, which is very exciting and promising. For the fans who wanted a modern pop ballad, this is it. I however would prefer a more soulful jazzy gospel sound for the album. Something I can feel, sink my teeth into, something on the order of the song snippet we heard on the B.W. interview or (in reference to the catalogue of gems) Vanishing, FLAB, I Wish You Well etc. Just not a totally pop album (or totally hip hop/ rap featured either). Having said that, I still feel the new song is a great refreshing sound for her. So I hope it catapult this era to coasting highs. (Tuesday 19 February 2013; 6:26)

Lee from UK (37,220) by RadChad from United States Yes, you did directly quote me, but you also twisted what I was trying to say with your following commentary. Which would make it out of context, it's possible to intepret things differently. Whether they paid her 18 million or 100 million,the show has to be edited and they're not going to edit based on who they paid the most for, they going to edit to their discretion, what they think works for the show, what they think people want to see. If they think pople want more Nicki, then that's what they're gonna get. As far as Mimi's judging, I guess pople just see what they see. So we'll just have to agree to disagree. (Sunday 17 February 2013; 17:29)

Idol editing (37,208) by RadChad from United States It's a fact that they've edited things out. Just watch the leaked Australian adverstiment. There's much we haven't seen. (Sunday 17 February 2013; 0:01)

Lee from the UK (37,206) by RadChad from United States You completely misinterpreted what I was saying. First off, I wasn't saying she would have to be the only female judge in order for her personality to shine on the show. I was more so saying that the tension from the feud, editing (don't forget that), and Nicki's agenda to prove herself, hog the spotlight, and upstage Mariah, has thrown the chemistry off and as a result it appears Mariah is holding back to keep the peace. Personally, I feel Mariah's presence speaks for itself on the show, I genuinely get happy when she finally gets a chance to speak, values her opinion, and sure the contestants feel the same. Mariah Carey does not have to be extra and compete with Nicki Minaj, because she is above it and has already proven herself worthy. I'm happy she's not giving in to Nicki's theatrics. I can't fathom how a die hard Mariah fan can watch the show and not see all this. What's ridiculous is actually comparing Mariah to Nicki Minaj in a less than way. Mariah needs to grow a pair? Really? Like I said, the live shows will reveal the truth. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 23:03)

Sigh of relief (37,200) by RadChad from United States It comforts my soul to know that they're still some lambs that see through the whole "Nicki is a better more eloquent judge" thing that's been playing out on here. I glad I'm not the only one that can see through all the slicing, dicing, and remixing of show; along with Nicki's motive of operation. We'll all know the truth during the live shows. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 2:11)

Re: eloquence by Billy from Greece (37,193) by RadChad from United States Exactly. I agree with you 100%. You would think some are new fans that just discovered Mariah, by the things they post on here. (Friday 15 February 2013; 17:14)

Mariah's justification (37,191) by RadChad from United States Judging from all the comparisons from you all, I completely understand now why Mariah was upset that she wasn't going to be the only female judge on AI and she had every right to be. And now you guys are saying Mariah isn't well spoken/eloquent on the show? It's really getting out of hand now. I'm not going to attack Nicki, because I was once a huge fan of hers, but I do believe that if Mariah was the only female judge, her personality would shine more and her critiques would be more in-depth/get more airtime. I think the tiff believe the two female judges didn't make for good television and has thrown the chemistry/comradery off. Hopefully during the live shows everything will begin to gel well. (Friday 15 February 2013; 15:33)

Not fooled by Nicki (37,147) by RadChad from United States During the altercation Nicki first tried the call Mariah and Randy out by saying "All you do is make comments about people in pop culture all day non stop." Now why was it necessary for her to say that? Then she said that "I feel that you all are forcing them to lie about the type of music they want to do." How is that when the girl already said she considers herself "country soul". Everybody agreed the girl had a great voice and said "yes" before Nicki when on her tangent. All she had to do is voice her opinion without attacking and others. Also I don't think Nicki gives better critique than Mariah. I think Nicki is just being "extra" and trying to prove herself. So that's why she hogs the spotlight, always trying to speak first, and purposely tries to one up Mariah during judging. I'm not impressed with her because it comes across as pretentious. Mariah comes across poised and confident and if I were a contestant, I would value Mariah's opinion more. It's the opposite for me, I loved Nicki before Idol, I always liked her personality and thought she was smart. Now, I see through her, she doesn't have me fooled. (Saturday 26 January 2013; 17:15)

The TV feud (37,140) by RadChad from United States Yes, Nicki raised a good point, however her delivery was awful. She could've made her point without attacking Mariah and Randy. They weren't even arguing over the point she was trying to make, but rather the accusations she made against them. Randy and Mariah have right to voice their opinions just as she does and I didn't see anything wrong with them telling that girl that her voice works well with country music. Of course she can try different genres, but you still have to know who you are as an artist. I think that's all they were trying to help her with. I felt that Nicki took that out of context and then blew it out of proportion. Fact that she would approach things that way in front of contestants was tacky and unprofessional IMO. It just came across as her having a chip on her shoulder. (Friday 25 January 2013; 23:18)

MORE MESSAGES