Messageboard

Serious question (112,642) by jaker20 from US For females there is none. I just hope she can write for other artists to be a complete songwriter. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 16:58) this is a reply to message 112,638

Serious question (112,638) by Lambi from USA Who is actually Mariah's closest formidable competition in terms of being a complete singer-songwriter? Is there anyone who genuinely matches her combination of vocal prowess and songwriting talent? Who? (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 11:21)

Sugar Plum Fairy Interlude (112,641) by MusicfanJ from Germany I started a bit late with listening to Christmas music, but now Mariah has got/enchanted me again. I still enjoy her deluxe edition from Merry Christmas. The sugar plum intro is so Mariah. The live versions from the church are a true gift. With the albums MC and MC2 I switch them with my mood of the day. I love MC2 but when I listen to Merry Christmas it also brings back memories. It was a better time, that I really miss. Mariah and the album reminds me of that. I'm very thankful for it. Funny side note: I watched the Peanuts movie and thought hey that's Mariah's intro. Lol. I hope you all enjoy the season although it's such a busy one. "Christmas time is here" is perfect for relaxation. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 16:24)

Serious question (112,640) by Lambi from USA Bobby A, you're too nice. I did the math, if you averaged all of Kelly Clarkson's records. She wrote about 35% of songs on her albums. Objectively, she's nowhere near Mariah's league. MC wrote all of the 11 tracks in her debut. Pretty much kept that same principle in all her records ever since, aside from the occasional covers. I thought JoJo was going to be Mariah's predecessor, she wrote 11 out the 14 tracks in her debut album. That's impressive for a 13 year old. She was innately prolific. And I thought she was going to keep developing her writing and become a solid writer as an adult, but nothing really much came of her career. It's actually kind of hard to think of another artist on par with Mariah's level of prolific songwriting and vocal excellence. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 13:45) this is a reply to message 112,639

Serious question (112,639) by Bobby A from United States Keith Sweat said nobody. Lol. I think he is right. Celine has never come close in her career because she is not a songwriter. Kelly Clarkson could have been if she didn't start her talk show. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 11:28)

Serious question (112,639) by Bobby A from United States Keith Sweat said nobody. Lol. I think he is right. Celine has never come close in her career because she is not a songwriter. Kelly Clarkson could have been if she didn't start her talk show. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 11:28) this is a reply to message 112,638

Serious question (112,638) by Lambi from USA Who is actually Mariah's closest formidable competition in terms of being a complete singer-songwriter? Is there anyone who genuinely matches her combination of vocal prowess and songwriting talent? Who? (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 11:21)

Serious question (112,638) by Lambi from USA Who is actually Mariah's closest formidable competition in terms of being a complete singer-songwriter? Is there anyone who genuinely matches her combination of vocal prowess and songwriting talent? Who? (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 11:21)

History in the making (112,637) by jaker20 from US It's absolutely crazy to think that Mariah owned the record for 25 years, then lose it and only to take it back. It's just mind-boggling. Also, I think I just replied to myself before this post. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 02:10) this is a reply to message 112,634

History in the making (112,634) by BFF from United States I love the fact that Mariah will be able to take the record back after "One Sweet Day" was surpassed by those awful songs by Lil' Nas X and Shaboozey. Mariah deserves to retake her place at the throne and all of the others can rightfully bow down. As Mariah would say, "I worked hard for this mess." (Tuesday 9 December 2025; 21:32)

Here For It All Christmas (112,636) by jaker20 from US Actually, I think the album is really a new step for her, she's embracing her current voice and hopefully taking a new artistic direction as her next step in her art. No over-stylized vocal, overly dramatic and lyrics about desperation and heavy emotional suffering over long lost love, and negative emotional heartbreak etc. etc. Just understated, soft and calm non-screaming vocals and messages of love, gentle optimism and inspiration in her lyrics that fans know her, but many likely don't. It's a back to basics, easy listening, adult-contemporary, just think of Music Box which many don't even know is great a song in her album. Or inspirational gospel-adjacent 70-80s turn of the decade breezy feeling sound. I hope she bring that back, some people are so negative and grouchy these days maybe they need it. And that could be new for her. Sure, they're not blockbuster top of the charts sounding pop songs, but for someone who's got an iconic song topping song breaking records for the gen z, why should she make more for the charts. This is a new direction for her and I hope she keeps on making them if the studios allow it. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 02:03) this is a reply to message 112,632

Here For It All Christmas (112,632) by jaker20 from US Well at least she is not ignoring the album altogether. This is what I wish she had done with Caution, incorporating materials from her latest album to her Christmas shows. I think that gives it some push, especially In Your Feelings which is currently number 2 on the R&B charts. Jesus I Do, My Love and In Your Feelings, even the fun uptempo I Wont Allow It would fit well into her Christmas setlist. (Tuesday 9 December 2025; 16:14)

Article: Waste/Dawn release metal cover of "All I Want for Christmas" (112,635) by Lee from USA I doubt that she is going to stop this facade because you're disillusioned. You're just screaming at the moon at this point. Despite the Sephora controversy, she still topped the Hot 100. Despite her vocal decline, she still sold out venues overseas. Despite her diva persona, she gets endorsement deals every year. I am not judging, but I would rather focus on the positives. (Wednesday 10 December 2025; 01:43) this is a reply to message 112,631

Article: Waste/Dawn release metal cover of "All I Want for Christmas" (112,631) by Geronimo from USA My sentiments exactly. Both "decay, disillusionment, and the desperate request to let the entire festive facade just end and the obvious need for switching the pop idol's longing for love with an agonizing demand for reality" is exactly how I am feeling. Mariah should give up the Christmas non-sense now since she cannot sing what she is performing and no one can afford to watch her lip synch - especially after she just released a great album with a singing voice that in no way matches her ruse. Enough already - this has gone far beyond absurd. (Tuesday 9 December 2025; 00:04)

History in the making (112,634) by BFF from United States I love the fact that Mariah will be able to take the record back after "One Sweet Day" was surpassed by those awful songs by Lil' Nas X and Shaboozey. Mariah deserves to retake her place at the throne and all of the others can rightfully bow down. As Mariah would say, "I worked hard for this mess." (Tuesday 9 December 2025; 21:32) this is a reply to message 112,629

History in the making (112,629) by Edward from USA It's official, "AIWFCIY" is back on top of the Billboard Hot 100. Lil Nas X better have that torch polished and ready, because it's heading right back to the queen next week. It should've never wandered out of her queendom to begin with. (Monday 8 December 2025; 21:55)

Queen of Christmas (112,633) by Dove from United States I'd like to see a Christmas music video of Mariah wearing Martha May Whovier's super festive outfits and replaying scenes from the movie. Especially the part where she's putting Christmas lights on her house. Jim Carey's version of The Grinch. But don't Who-ify her. Keep her face human. (Tuesday 9 December 2025; 16:59)

Here For It All Christmas (112,632) by jaker20 from US Well at least she is not ignoring the album altogether. This is what I wish she had done with Caution, incorporating materials from her latest album to her Christmas shows. I think that gives it some push, especially In Your Feelings which is currently number 2 on the R&B charts. Jesus I Do, My Love and In Your Feelings, even the fun uptempo I Wont Allow It would fit well into her Christmas setlist. (Tuesday 9 December 2025; 16:14)

Article: Waste/Dawn release metal cover of "All I Want for Christmas" (112,631) by Geronimo from USA My sentiments exactly. Both "decay, disillusionment, and the desperate request to let the entire festive facade just end and the obvious need for switching the pop idol's longing for love with an agonizing demand for reality" is exactly how I am feeling. Mariah should give up the Christmas non-sense now since she cannot sing what she is performing and no one can afford to watch her lip synch - especially after she just released a great album with a singing voice that in no way matches her ruse. Enough already - this has gone far beyond absurd. (Tuesday 9 December 2025; 00:04)

Would you rather? (112,630) by jaker20 from US I hope Mariah gets as many weeks as she can with AIWFC because as we have seen in the last 5 years, it's quite easy to get 15+ weeks at number one 1 now. Apart from Lile Nas' record, just a year ago, that Bar Song also did 18 weeks. Harry Styles' As It Was would have done 25 weeks if it wasn't for a few songs being released in between it. Same with Morgan Wallen's Last Night would have done 23 weeks+. So it not that hard anymore. Because outside of the Christmas season, the chart points are so low most of the time. In fact it's only during this season that chart points are so high across multiple songs. That just shows how impressive AIWFCIY domination is. So if it's about records, she should take this as far as she can because all these records are meant to be broken. (Monday 8 December 2025; 23:25) this is a reply to message 112,603

Would you rather? (112,603) by T from USA If you could only chose one. Would you rather Mariah have the record for the longest running #1 hit or the most #1 hits? Scenario 1) AIWFCIY is number one for three more weeks giving it a total of twenty one weeks, and 100 weeks in total on the Hot 100. Scenario 2) AIWFCIY stalls forever at eighteen weeks, but her next two singles (featured or solo) go to #1, and so her all time Hot 100 total is 99 weeks. Pick one. (Friday 5 December 2025; 23:55)

History in the making (112,629) by Edward from USA It's official, "AIWFCIY" is back on top of the Billboard Hot 100. Lil Nas X better have that torch polished and ready, because it's heading right back to the queen next week. It should've never wandered out of her queendom to begin with. (Monday 8 December 2025; 21:55)

Nr.1? (112,628) by Hanno van Leeuwen from The Netherlands Congratulations MC. Back at nr. 1 at the Billboard Hot 100 with All I Want For Christmas Is You, the best Christmas song ever. Merry Christmas? (Monday 8 December 2025; 21:17)

2026 Plans for Here For It All? (112,627) by Jamie from UK I agree Vegas is crazy expensive at the best of times these days and visits to the city are down because people can't afford the inflated prices there. If the tourist numbers are down which they keep reporting then there's less people to go to shows like Mariah's and various others. Sooner they stop the greed of these huge corporations ripping everyone off the better, the economy can't sustain like this. I personally feel this year has gone so quickly I'm like is it really Christmas already. (Monday 8 December 2025; 10:51) this is a reply to message 112,612

2026 Plans for Here For It All? (112,612) by Edward from USA Bobby A, sadly there's probably not going to be an "HFIA" Deluxe Edition. Outside of her hardcore fans, nobody seem to care about the album. Mariah and Gamma aren't about to keep throwing money at something that isn't giving anything back. At the end of the day, Gamma is a business. It was a joint version, and both parties did what they could. You wouldn't keep pouring water into a bottomless barrel expecting it to get full, would you? And the whole "Mariah's Christmas popularity is fading" thing? Not really. The economy is just trash right now. Everything is expensive, people are losing jobs, and most folks are just trying to survive the holidays, not spend on unnecessary things like flights and concert tickets. Competition is tough in Vegas when Mariah doesn't bring anything new to her shows. Even with all that, Mariah's still doing her thing. Bublé's Christmas is 14 years old, Merry Christmas is 31 years old, and the fact that her album is back up at #14 (and looking to jump into the top 10 next week) is wild. That's not someone "declining", that's someone with ridiculous staying power. I don't think she should've moved her Christmas show to Vegas. It kinda took away that warm, cozy, classic Mariah holiday vibe. It worked better when it was more intimate and easier for fans to get to. She reigned supreme at Beacon Theater for a decade and she also did great at MSG. Both venues were a train away for most people. (Saturday 6 December 2025; 14:59)

Would you rather? (112,626) by Lainsky from Philippines It would be nice to have both, but I go more for scenario 2. Yes, Swift may break it sooner or later, but also maybe not. And she will maintain this record for years. I always wanted to see her have two more No. 1 songs on the Billboard Hot 100. So I hope she will release two killer singles either from HFAI, a new edition, or a newly recorded one. Just wishing and saying. (Monday 8 December 2025; 09:19) this is a reply to message 112,603

Would you rather? (112,603) by T from USA If you could only chose one. Would you rather Mariah have the record for the longest running #1 hit or the most #1 hits? Scenario 1) AIWFCIY is number one for three more weeks giving it a total of twenty one weeks, and 100 weeks in total on the Hot 100. Scenario 2) AIWFCIY stalls forever at eighteen weeks, but her next two singles (featured or solo) go to #1, and so her all time Hot 100 total is 99 weeks. Pick one. (Friday 5 December 2025; 23:55)

Would you rather? (112,625) by Zachariah from Croatia I tried to like her and her music - I just can't. I tried. But I can't. I can't relate, I don't like the sound and I just don't get it. (Monday 8 December 2025; 07:34) this is a reply to message 112,617

Would you rather? (112,617) by Dove from United States I became a fan of Taylor when she was on a show on MTV. She was young, probably 15. I don't remember the show but she was going to the prom with a regular guy, as like, a prize. She was so sweet and humble. I immediately liked her and looked her up. I had already heard some of her songs on the radio but after that I started buying her albums and going to her shows. She seemed like a sweet girl who I would be friends with. I like how her songs were about things a girl her age would actually be going through and as she grew up her songs evolved with her. I didn't love her latest album at first listen but it has grown on me and now I love it. I really like the song Father Figure. About the record question: I would choose the option Edward said. At first I was going for the other option but his argument changed my mind. (Sunday 7 December 2025; 01:22)

Article: Waste/Dawn release metal cover of "All I Want for Christmas" (112,624) by Dove from United States I love it. Haha. (Monday 8 December 2025; 01:56)

Would you rather? (112,623) by Terna from Nigeria Taylor checks all the boxes for an ideal pop star, makes catchy, hook heavy pop music that's very easy to sing along to and for her to sing live, has an ok voice, that's just right and has a formula that works and sticks to it. She also has a very good and efficient team backing her up. But it's her material that's the charm actually. In the words of Diana Ross from the movie she did with Brandy (Double Platinum) her character said, "You could be the most talented singer in the world but if you're singing the wrong songs, you're not going anywhere. Aretha Franklin suffered this early on in her career - great voice, wrong material." I guess Taylor knows this. Mariah Carey knows this secret too also being a songwriter (and she's got an ear for music too don't forget). Her pen game, musicianship (Mariah knows music) and diversity in different genres, over time has led to a solid discography that speaks for itself. Prince is another artist that comes to mind. (Sunday 7 December 2025; 23:26) this is a reply to message 112,606

Would you rather? (112,606) by TJ from Norway I really don't understand why TS is so popular. It's like people are under a spell. (Saturday 6 December 2025; 09:45)

Would you rather? (112,622) by jaker20 from US The problem with the charts now is the "double count". The streams of one song count to the album and vice versa. There is no way to split them, so technically charts don't mean anything anymore. The charts are dead now. I feel like Taylor is just gaming the system. She got 8 weeks at no.1 on a song by releasing multiple variants. She does not even perform her songs anymore outside of her concerts, and they stay at number 1. In the past, Mariah had to perform her song multiple times across different shows and countries over the period of weeks for them to become hits. It's no longer about the song now, but just about riding the artists' popularity. I think Mariah should focus on protecting her catalog instead of the charts. AIWFCIY will be her true legacy, not the charts, long after Billboard is dead and defunct. Especially with AI music inevitably coming. (Sunday 7 December 2025; 22:16)

Would you rather? (112,621) by MusicfanJ from Germany I completely agree. Taylor Swift may be a good entertainer (but nothing special). But she is very smart with business and partners and has a very good image. MJ was a phenomenon. Oh yes, he was. Pure talent I witnessed through the whole 90ies. What he started with the Jackson's 5 and later as a solo artist is unique. I miss his music so much. When I hear the "Earth song", "They don't care about us", "Who is it", "Dirty Diana" or "Stranger in Moscow" on my radio station I often get goosebumps. What a sound. Something I never get with the all the other songs on the radio, except Mariah's ballads or with "Sitting on the dock on the bay". MJ will always be the King of Pop. There will never be another one. (Sunday 7 December 2025; 14:40) this is a reply to message 112,614

Would you rather? (112,614) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Bobby A I adore you, but please let's never compare Taylor to MJ. This is coming from someone who listens to Taylor's music and I too have quote how Taylor is definitely a master marketing machine. But MJ is on a league of his own and his career hasn't been matched and won't ever be matched. Beyoncé tried and failed. MJ was a phenomenon, a total powerhouse and launched a billion careers due to his influence especially at a time where there was no social media. He was pure talent, no gimmicks, no clever marketing. He was just the kind of artist we will probably never experience again. Taylor Swift is a powerhouse in her own right but I don't think she is of Michael's caliber and influence. She knows how to control the narrative and market herself and that's what works for her. (Saturday 6 December 2025; 17:00)

2026 Plans for Here For It All? (112,620) by Bobby A from United States Edward, you brought up some valid points. I need to stop clicking on every link about MC in newsfeed. I read the article and then I start believe the author's opinion about MC. (Sunday 7 December 2025; 14:07) this is a reply to message 112,612

2026 Plans for Here For It All? (112,612) by Edward from USA Bobby A, sadly there's probably not going to be an "HFIA" Deluxe Edition. Outside of her hardcore fans, nobody seem to care about the album. Mariah and Gamma aren't about to keep throwing money at something that isn't giving anything back. At the end of the day, Gamma is a business. It was a joint version, and both parties did what they could. You wouldn't keep pouring water into a bottomless barrel expecting it to get full, would you? And the whole "Mariah's Christmas popularity is fading" thing? Not really. The economy is just trash right now. Everything is expensive, people are losing jobs, and most folks are just trying to survive the holidays, not spend on unnecessary things like flights and concert tickets. Competition is tough in Vegas when Mariah doesn't bring anything new to her shows. Even with all that, Mariah's still doing her thing. Bublé's Christmas is 14 years old, Merry Christmas is 31 years old, and the fact that her album is back up at #14 (and looking to jump into the top 10 next week) is wild. That's not someone "declining", that's someone with ridiculous staying power. I don't think she should've moved her Christmas show to Vegas. It kinda took away that warm, cozy, classic Mariah holiday vibe. It worked better when it was more intimate and easier for fans to get to. She reigned supreme at Beacon Theater for a decade and she also did great at MSG. Both venues were a train away for most people. (Saturday 6 December 2025; 14:59)

Would you rather? (112,619) by Bobby A from United States Mimi, I saw that I only had 1 like. Lol. I am going to stop reading her Wikipedia page. (Sunday 7 December 2025; 14:02) this is a reply to message 112,614

Would you rather? (112,614) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Bobby A I adore you, but please let's never compare Taylor to MJ. This is coming from someone who listens to Taylor's music and I too have quote how Taylor is definitely a master marketing machine. But MJ is on a league of his own and his career hasn't been matched and won't ever be matched. Beyoncé tried and failed. MJ was a phenomenon, a total powerhouse and launched a billion careers due to his influence especially at a time where there was no social media. He was pure talent, no gimmicks, no clever marketing. He was just the kind of artist we will probably never experience again. Taylor Swift is a powerhouse in her own right but I don't think she is of Michael's caliber and influence. She knows how to control the narrative and market herself and that's what works for her. (Saturday 6 December 2025; 17:00)

Christmas Vegas shows (112,618) by Dove from United States Are they recording some of her Vegas Christmas shows? I like watching them. I wish we could buy some of them from previous years. I like watching them but some are only available through subscription services and I'm not going to subscribe to only watch one thing. The other day Mariah Carey's Magical Christmas Special popped up when I was listening to Christmas music and I was surprised at how good she sounded. I usually don't go for that one. I was pleasantly surprised. (Sunday 7 December 2025; 01:29)

MORE MESSAGES