Messageboard

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER

A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,055) by Lighty from China
They are still there but the fan cams mostly just focus on Mariah. Enjoy the full show here. [Webmaster: See an earlier message from D.]
(Friday 20 November 2026; 04:29)
this is a reply to message 115,052
Greatness doesn't have to sound the same (115,054) by Lighty from China
Of course Mariah doesn't have to sound the same, but at least act normal.
(Friday 20 November 2026; 04:20)
this is a reply to message 115,053
Greatness doesn't have to sound the same (115,053) by D from United States
If a person is a fan of Beethoven and he loses two of his fingers, someone who loves his work will still go see him perform in person, if only to be in the presence of greatness, knowing full well that it isn't going to sound as great as it did when he first composed those pieces.

I don't believe Mariah has "lost it". She might not be able to move or sing as well as she once could, but I have faith that her compositional genius hasn't reached its peak yet. People with talent like hers, Beethoven's, or Brian Wilson's can hear music internally. They imagine whole symphonies in their heads.

I went to see Brian Wilson when everyone said he was washed up and "not worth it". I believe that people with talent like that have special favor from God. They must have been extraordinary souls to be given gifts that allow them to heal and uplift other souls.

I grieve the fact that Mariah never learned to play an instrument because all of that magic is gestating inside of her, trapped, without an easy way to find its expression. On a side note, I wish every young person were required to learn to play an instrument, whether they're good at it or not.

I was thinking about Beethoven lately, so I looked him up and discovered that "after he lost his hearing, because he could no longer hear the audience's reactions or social expectations, his late music became more experimental, emotionally raw, and ahead of its time. Critics of his time thought his deafness made his music sound strange, but future generations embraced those exact pieces as revolutionary masterpieces." (I'm putting that whole paragraph in quotation marks because I pulled it from an opinion piece.)

Mariah's music has always been ahead of its time. She should do what she wants to do, and eventually the people who are supposed to get it will get it. People may not like her new voice, but some of us still do. Nobody is required to be a fan of every single thing an artist does. We have free will. If you want someone whose performances are closer to perfection, go find someone else to spend your time and money on. There is an overabundance of talented artists out there right now.

I do appreciate the younger set who are hungrier and more driven, but as a woman in my 40s, I appreciate Mariah. She's done a lot already. She's living at a leisurely pace now, as she should. It makes me feel like I can, too.

And just a thought I had about her shoes. As a person who has also always walked on the balls of my feet, flat shoes aren't comfortable either. Someone needs to design a line of cute shoes for us. I like the boots Shakira wore at her Super Bowl performance. The boots I wore forever are really ugly, but they hold my feet just right. They're the Rocket Dog Side Step boots. But size up and buy an extra insole. Used pairs are better because they used to be made better than they are now.
(Friday 20 November 2026; 02:14)
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,052) by Bobby A from United States
Something financial seems fishing about the Firefly tour now. I just don't understand why she is obligating herself to do a summer festival concert during outside venues considering the state of her voice and when MC17 has not been given a release date. I just wonder if MC needs the cash to finance the recording of MC17 because .gamma doesn't finance recording sessions and mastering.

Also, has anyone else noticed that Trey, Mary Ann and Sharlene don't tour with MC anymore? Maybe the three of them couldn't take anymore of MC lip syncing during performances.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 23:30)
this is a reply to message 115,045
I'm gonna go against the grain a bit (115,051) by Randy from USA
BFF you are hilarious. I do wanna say. After reading the book and seeing her Emancipation 100% live with only piano performance, I can't ask anymore of MC. I feel sorry for her. She can't perform like she used to and has to work to fund her extravagant lifestyle. In a world where Michael, Whitney, Prince and Luther are gone, I am just happy she is still here. But I know not to buy any concert tickets.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 21:10)
Article: Mariah sparks concern with overly "stiff" performance (115,050) by nancy from Switzerland
I am curious to know. Is it the management who forces Mariah to do the shows because she signed a contract to fulfill the obligations? Her expensive lifestyle that she wants to keep? She really ruins her reputation that way. She still can make music and put and album every 3 years.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 19:07)
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,049) by BFF from US
I love her recent performances. When I watch the videos, I think to myself... "Yaaaas Queen Yaaaas. I like everything, and this is something." The Divine McCarey does divadom so well she doesn't even have to move her body or her lips. She can literally do nothing on stage, and she just exudes the divine essence of sacred divas past and present.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 17:07)
this is a reply to message 115,045
Mariah Carey - Live In São Paulo X / Brazil - 2026 (115,048) by Lighty from China
She rarely tours is the funniest thing I've heard in a while.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 16:46)
this is a reply to message 115,046
Mariah Carey - Live In São Paulo X / Brazil - 2026 (115,047) by Bill from the UK
You're delusional, you're delusional, boy you're losing your mind.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 16:05)
this is a reply to message 115,046
Mariah Carey - Live In São Paulo X / Brazil - 2026 (115,046) by D from United States
I've been extra busy this past week and was saving this concert as a treat for my day off, but I just had to watch it after reading all of your reviews. I just watched some of the video, and so far, I haven't seen her about to fall - not once. I'm wondering why everyone is being so dramatic. Mariah has never been one to move a ton. She doesn't even look as stiff at this show as she has at other times. She looks happy and like she actually wants to be there.

As far as I know, she rarely tours. She usually just does a few Christmas shows every year and a few special events. I feel like I'm being gaslit because what you all are describing is not what I'm seeing.

We don't know that she's dying. Are you serious?. We don't even know what's wrong with her, if anything. I highly doubt she's in a Britney situation where she's being forced to perform. It doesn't seem that way to me at all.

She sounds great. She sounds like she did in 2009 at the Pearl Palms Concert Theatre. She's never going to sound like she did during Butterfly and Daydream again. Do we expect her to? I can't even tell that she's lip-syncing, and she looks great. The ensembles are some of the best I've seen her in.

I was concerned when I saw the video of her in the rain with the assistant holding on to her, but then she was walking just fine in flats the next day. She's walking fine in the concert I'm watching right now, too.

If there is something wrong health-wise and she doesn't want to tell everyone, I'm fine with that. I'm sure she has her reasons, and she will disclose it when and if she's ready.

I thought about it, and I was wrong about what I said about "keeping an eye on her". I was thinking about Britney and how we never see her anymore, so we don't even know if she's still alive. What I was trying to say is that I like seeing Mariah each Christmas season because at least I know she's still alive.

If it were an Ariana Grande situation, where she actually looks like she's going to collapse before our eyes, I'd be onboard with forcing her to take a vacation. I don't think we're anywhere close to that.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 15:46)
this is a reply to message 115,037
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,045) by Edward from USA
I don't think any real fan wants to see her putting herself through this. It's sad watching someone we've admired for so many years looking so stiff on stage, needing her dancers to help her move around, and badly lipping through most of the show. And knowing that the whole world is watching, waiting to pick apart every little thing and make fun of her, makes it even worse.

Being a fan doesn't mean you have to defend everything she does or pretend these performances are acceptable. Sometimes you just wish she'd take a step back and stop putting herself in these situations. She has nothing left to prove. I really don't see the point of continuing to push these less than mediocre lipped performances. It's not doing her any favors.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 14:31)
this is a reply to message 115,044
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,044) by Lara from Middle East
Sadly, I think these fans are her incentive to perform. "I'm doing the best I can with what I got." True fans are content with that and appreciate her effort. Other true fans aren't because they see it's stretching her too thin and it's nowhere close to the old Mariah. Both are true fans, both ways are sad for Mariah.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 12:56)
this is a reply to message 115,042
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,043) by BFF from US
I don't know what people are complaining about. These are arguably some of the best performances of her career. I love the way she hit the spoken notes on "How you feeling?" at the beginning of the concert. The pre-recorded vocals sounded so natural and well-rested. And she worked hard to change her facial expressions and move her hands to emote the depth of meaning within the songs.

The best treatments for the ultra rare disorder stiff lip syndrome are as follows: splashes throughout the day, periodic glam moments, sleeping until 5 pm, no live singing, limited lip syncing, no strenuous movement, 20 hours of sleep before shows, etc. It's a very hard illness to live with, dah-lings.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 12:52)
this is a reply to message 115,038
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,042) by Edward from USA
And they would be like: "Yass queen, only you can collapse with such style." Some of these "yass queen" lambs are too much. She shouldn't be on stage in that condition, period. She's ruining her legacy and it's a disrespect to her audience.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 12:44)
this is a reply to message 115,041
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,041) by Bill from the UK
So are you just waiting for her to collapse and die on stage then? Hey, at least you'll be at the front row.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 12:11)
this is a reply to message 115,038
These lips are made for syncing (115,040) by Lighty from China
Guess what, there're still delusional ones here.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 12:09)
this is a reply to message 115,036
These lips are made for syncing (115,039) by Lara from Middle East
I think she's overusing her diva image to hide and give an excuse for her condition. She was a diva in 2005. The heels, the attitude, the ensembles. She acts now as a "lazy" diva. It's more and more obvious there's something medically wrong, but when will she admit it, God only knows.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 10:13)
this is a reply to message 115,036
A lifetime of music deserves a lifetime of respect (115,038) by Armen from United States
It's sad to see some of the comments here. Y'all claim to be real Mariah fans, but this is what support looks like? At this point, be grateful that you're fortunate enough to see her perform. She has given all of us a-lifetime gift through her music and her talent. If you're genuinely concerned, then pray for her and wish her well. Stop criticizing, judging, and talking negatively. Being a fan should mean showing love and support, not tearing someone down.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 10:00)
Mariah Carey - Live In São Paulo X / Brazil - 2026 (115,037) by D from United States
I couldn't watch it yet, but I had it playing in the background and I would buy this if it were a live album.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 09:26)
These lips are made for syncing (115,036) by Bill from the UK
Well, well, well. Isn't it interesting how we're suddenly all having these conversations now?

For years, a collection of fans have been pointing out the very same things: the increasing reliance on lip-syncing, the lack of genuine live performances, the increasingly uncomfortable-looking stage appearances, the questionable creative decisions and the general feeling that something has been off for quite some time.

And what happened whenever anyone dared mention it? Accusations of being negative, ungrateful, bitter, not a real fan or simply hating on Mariah. Apparently, being a fan meant enthusiastically applauding absolutely everything and pretending not to have eyes or ears.

Fast forward to 2026 and suddenly everyone's concerned, everyone's noticing, everyone's asking questions and expressing the very same opinions that were dismissed for years.

Perhaps the most exhausting part isn't what's happening now, but the years spent being shot down for daring to acknowledge it.

The longer this mysterious illness remains shrouded in secrecy, the more room there is for speculation, the more uncomfortable the questions become, and the less forgiving the press and fans will inevitably be. Silence might buy time, but it rarely buys goodwill.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 07:28)
Article: Mariah sparks concern with overly "stiff" performance (115,035) by D from United States
I've only watched a few clips, but it doesn't look that bad. I feel like most people know what they're getting when they go to a Mariah concert. She does the best she can with what she's got, and I'd rather have this over nothing. This way, we can at least keep an eye on her. It probably sounds better when you're actually there, and nostalgia likely takes over. The concert clips I've watched aren't any worse than the Christmas specials she's put out. The official "Glitter Medley (Live from the Caution Tour)" track sounds a lot better than the low-quality clips on YouTube. Her voice has changed and it's not going to sound like it did in her prime.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 06:50)
Brazil concert (115,034) by Bobby A from United States
I meant to type her 2013 fall.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 04:14)
this is a reply to message 115,032
Article: Mariah sparks concern with overly "stiff" performance (115,033) by Lainsky from Philippines
After seeing the concert reels, I quietly thought, "The fans will not let this go unnoticed. It'll spark numerous and varied comments." And it did. I concur with some of those comments, though.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 04:08)
Brazil concert (115,032) by Bobby A from United States
It is sad to watch. It just dawned on me why MC has stopped doing U.S. shows. The U.S. media and social media would report about it and tear her to pieces. Their reporting would be too devasting for MC. I don't think she could take it this time. Reddit and X posters and have been so cruel recently to singers who can't sing live. They have not been nice this year to those artists. MC is definitely saving herself from reliving 2017.

Could her in 2014 fall have caused her now utterly awardness doing normal gross and fine motor functions? She was definitely good with her stage presence before 2014. It has to be the effects of her fall.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 02:33)
this is a reply to message 115,028
Brazil concert (115,031) by BFF from US
She had to use the 2009 recordings because she didn't have enough vocal rest to allow her to pre-record new 2026 vocals. She had to change ensembles as part of her Gucci endorsement deal, and ensemble changes are a part of her post-modern social commentary on the struggles of being a diva in a post-diva world. People just don't understand the performance art aspect of Mariah's shows.

I thought the ad-libbed "Yeahs" and "Heys" were really beautiful. She powered through stiff lip syndrome to delivered some really great notes for Brazilian lambs.
(Thursday 19 November 2026; 02:20)
this is a reply to message 115,028

MORE MESSAGES

Only registrated members can post messages. Registration is free.
LOG IN REGISTER



If you want to leave a message, there are a few rules you must follow:
1. This is a Mariah Carey messageboard, so the message must be related to Mariah Carey.
2. Only messages in English will be posted. And please try to write understandable English, with the proper use of dots and capitals.
3. Messages with all capitals will be ignored.
4. Messages that are insulting (to Mariah, other artists or members of this messageboard) will not be posted.
The webmaster has the right to refuse any message he doesn't like.
© MCArchives 1998-2026 (28 years!)
NEWS
MESSAGEBOARD