Messageboard

A theory on Mariah's nodules (113,260) by Lighty from China Do you guys agree with what this video says? And there are also some little discussions about Mariah's nodules as well as her mental state in the comment section you might be interested in. (Sunday 15 February 2026; 12:58)

The humble beginning (113,259) by Stacey from USA I watched that very video today. Wow, just wow. (Sunday 15 February 2026; 06:19) this is a reply to message 113,256

The humble beginning (113,256) by Lainsky from Philippines To the younger lambs, if you have not seen this raw footage of her live debut, where it all started, here it is. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 14:00)

MC's next album (113,258) by Giovanni from USA I agree, Butterfly was Mariah's escape from Tommy and she was able to be free and do the music she wanted. It's definitely probably her best album. (Sunday 15 February 2026; 00:24) this is a reply to message 113,254

MC's next album (113,254) by Lighty from China IMHO Butterfly, Charmbracelet, Memoirs are the three most personal albums from Mariah but Butterfly is and will always be "the" most personal one no matter what kind of album she puts out next. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 08:29)

MC's next album (113,257) by Bobby A from United States There is still another deeply personal album left in MC. Butterfly was a personal album because it was the album where she became liberated from a tough personal period in her life. One more personal album in 2029 may yield the Grammy moment that MC has been waiting for. Plus, Roc and Roe will be 18 years old in 2029. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 14:47) this is a reply to message 113,254

MC's next album (113,254) by Lighty from China IMHO Butterfly, Charmbracelet, Memoirs are the three most personal albums from Mariah but Butterfly is and will always be "the" most personal one no matter what kind of album she puts out next. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 08:29)

The humble beginning (113,256) by Lainsky from Philippines To the younger lambs, if you have not seen this raw footage of her live debut, where it all started, here it is. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 14:00)

Nodules (113,255) by Sasha from Nomansland For someone who always wanted to be recognized first and foremost for her writing skills, she really missed something. It could be an ego thing as you say. She still has many positive things to bring to the music world but no longer on stage in the way she does now. It doesn't work anymore. Her voice no longer does justice to her songs that's why I think she would be better off writing for other artists or pursue other ventures. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 11:32) this is a reply to message 113,249

Nodules (113,249) by jaker20 from US "I just don't understand why she didn't turn to write and produce for other artists. It could have been a second career. Too bad." She should have done it a long time ago, like 20 years ago just after TEOM. Maybe there's truth to allegations that she's jealous of young artists, so she continued to chase her own success instead. But that's around the right time for her to learn how to write for other artists, that's what the great pop artist who were great songwriters did, Paul McCartney, Carole King, Prince, etc. Now, the older she gets, the harder it is to write for others, and harder to collaborate. Because Mariah's songwriting process is very different. She needed to collaborate with musicians who play the harmony and she writes the words in her head from that harmony. And because she doesn't know how to collaborate with other artists in that way, the songwriting got rusty as well. I think Mariah's career got lucky with AIWFCIY because she's now able to rewrite her story and legacy, including inserting "songwriter" into it, which is what sets her apart from her contemporaries. But that legacy fails on close inspection because she really doesn't know how to write for others. (Friday 13 February 2026; 20:26)

MC's next album (113,254) by Lighty from China IMHO Butterfly, Charmbracelet, Memoirs are the three most personal albums from Mariah but Butterfly is and will always be "the" most personal one no matter what kind of album she puts out next. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 08:29) this is a reply to message 113,251

MC's next album (113,251) by Bobby A from United States Do you think MC's next album will have to be her most personal album to date? I think MC needs to create a body of work that has a bold relatable album title that makes the non-Lamb scrolling on social media say, "Hmmm?" The album has to read like a personal diary with an infusion of jazz, pop, dance, and R&B. I want to hear more of the good, the bad, and the ugly next time. MC is going have to make a bold personal statement with her next album like Jill Scott did today. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 00:39)

MC's next album (113,253) by Giovanni from USA I hope we don't have to wait another 7 years for the next album lol. And as you had mentioned Nostalgic or Nostalgia would be a good album title. It's strong and makes sense if Mariah wants to make a record that reminds her remaining fans of her past work. HFIA had potential with IYF and NII but as I brought up recently it really doesn't matter how good her next album is if the voice doesn't sound good. I am hoping something changes and she gets it back in better shape ala Caution. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 02:57) this is a reply to message 113,251

MC's next album (113,251) by Bobby A from United States Do you think MC's next album will have to be her most personal album to date? I think MC needs to create a body of work that has a bold relatable album title that makes the non-Lamb scrolling on social media say, "Hmmm?" The album has to read like a personal diary with an infusion of jazz, pop, dance, and R&B. I want to hear more of the good, the bad, and the ugly next time. MC is going have to make a bold personal statement with her next album like Jill Scott did today. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 00:39)

Nodules (113,252) by Giovanni from USA I love the AI version of "My love", f you ask me it would have fit perfectly on the Butterfly album. I would have swapped out "Whenever you call" as it's one of the few songs from Mariah I don't care for. I imagine "Jesus I do" in Music Box voice or Emancipation voice. Speaking of "Jesus I do", I want Mariah to work with Kirk Franklin for another gospel number. I love "Jesus I do" and I love "Fly like a bird". I feel "Fly like a bird" is a personal song for Mariah and one most of us love. I also have a great love for "I pray" and wished it was longer and had made it on TEOM. I wish we had gotten a gospel album in 2015 instead of another greatest hits none of us needed. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 02:43) this is a reply to message 113,248

Nodules (113,248) by Stacey from USA Well said. There is an AI version of My Love (Butterfly era) floating around the internet. Wow. Check that one out. There is one thing, though, that does unite all these vocal eras - the songwriter. No matter how Mariah's voice has changed, no matter what era is used to create an AI version of one of her songs, there is one constant in all of this - the songwriter. Those lyrics are truly what makes her music so special. (Friday 13 February 2026; 18:16)

MC's next album (113,251) by Bobby A from United States Do you think MC's next album will have to be her most personal album to date? I think MC needs to create a body of work that has a bold relatable album title that makes the non-Lamb scrolling on social media say, "Hmmm?" The album has to read like a personal diary with an infusion of jazz, pop, dance, and R&B. I want to hear more of the good, the bad, and the ugly next time. MC is going have to make a bold personal statement with her next album like Jill Scott did today. (Saturday 14 February 2026; 00:39)

Nodules (113,250) by Zachariah from Croatia I just went to hear it. This is so good. (Friday 13 February 2026; 22:27) this is a reply to message 113,246

Nodules (113,246) by Sasha from Nomansland I feel a bit ashamed but I enjoy much more AI version of IYF. It is what it is, everything has an end and she's done enough. I just don't understand why she didn't turn to write and produce for other artists. It could have been a second career. Too bad. (Friday 13 February 2026; 08:35)

Nodules (113,249) by jaker20 from US "I just don't understand why she didn't turn to write and produce for other artists. It could have been a second career. Too bad." She should have done it a long time ago, like 20 years ago just after TEOM. Maybe there's truth to allegations that she's jealous of young artists, so she continued to chase her own success instead. But that's around the right time for her to learn how to write for other artists, that's what the great pop artist who were great songwriters did, Paul McCartney, Carole King, Prince, etc. Now, the older she gets, the harder it is to write for others, and harder to collaborate. Because Mariah's songwriting process is very different. She needed to collaborate with musicians who play the harmony and she writes the words in her head from that harmony. And because she doesn't know how to collaborate with other artists in that way, the songwriting got rusty as well. I think Mariah's career got lucky with AIWFCIY because she's now able to rewrite her story and legacy, including inserting "songwriter" into it, which is what sets her apart from her contemporaries. But that legacy fails on close inspection because she really doesn't know how to write for others. (Friday 13 February 2026; 20:26) this is a reply to message 113,246

Nodules (113,246) by Sasha from Nomansland I feel a bit ashamed but I enjoy much more AI version of IYF. It is what it is, everything has an end and she's done enough. I just don't understand why she didn't turn to write and produce for other artists. It could have been a second career. Too bad. (Friday 13 February 2026; 08:35)

Nodules (113,248) by Stacey from USA Well said. There is an AI version of My Love (Butterfly era) floating around the internet. Wow. Check that one out. There is one thing, though, that does unite all these vocal eras - the songwriter. No matter how Mariah's voice has changed, no matter what era is used to create an AI version of one of her songs, there is one constant in all of this - the songwriter. Those lyrics are truly what makes her music so special. (Friday 13 February 2026; 18:16) this is a reply to message 113,245

Nodules (113,245) by Giovanni from USA It's okay Stacey, I also listen to AI versions of Mariah as well. For me it's not so much me wishing she still sounded like her younger self it's just for fun. We all have our own fantasy Mariah song covers we wish she had covered. The AI version of IYF in Daydream voice is so addictive and amazing. I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting Mariah to get her voice back in shape I just think she doesn't care anymore. I'm still listening to Caution and HFIA regularly though. NIA has become of my favorites along with "Jesus I do". (Friday 13 February 2026; 06:04)

TMB (113,247) by Bobby A from United States Touch My Body is one my favorite the "sound of Atlanta" songs. It came out at a time when MC's voice got better after she lost weight. Also, It seemed like her popularity increased during this time as well. TMB was a fun period for MC and her 18th #1 single. It would be another career moment if she could score her 20th number one in the next three years. (Friday 13 February 2026; 11:26) this is a reply to message 113,244

TMB (113,244) by Lainsky from Philippines "Touch My Body" trended on X, celebrating its achievement of becoming Mariah Carey's 18th No. 1 hit. She looks amazing in the various live performances of this song. Back then, she was in her late 30s, but her figure was at its peak - sexy and healthy at the same time. It's clear that she embodied the song's themes and made sure her body was "worth touching". As for the track itself, I was captivated from the moment I first heard it. It doesn't feature any whistle notes or extensive belting, and it has a fun, relaxing vibe. The music video perfectly complements the song's feel. Even now, she can still perform this song beautifully, showcasing the quality of her current voice. (Friday 13 February 2026; 04:53)

Nodules (113,246) by Sasha from Nomansland I feel a bit ashamed but I enjoy much more AI version of IYF. It is what it is, everything has an end and she's done enough. I just don't understand why she didn't turn to write and produce for other artists. It could have been a second career. Too bad. (Friday 13 February 2026; 08:35) this is a reply to message 113,242

Nodules (113,242) by Stacey from USA I absolutely love the messages from HFIA, song and album. But I'd be lying to myself if I wasn't a bit conflicted when listening to these songs given her current voice. It's just not the same. I feel like such a cop out seeking AI versions of HFIA, IYF and NII using Butterfly and/or Daydream vocals, preferring to listen to those versions sometimes. At the end of the day, I can't be too sad. I have such an amazing, unmatched by anyone catalog of music to listen to. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 17:32)

Nodules (113,245) by Giovanni from USA It's okay Stacey, I also listen to AI versions of Mariah as well. For me it's not so much me wishing she still sounded like her younger self it's just for fun. We all have our own fantasy Mariah song covers we wish she had covered. The AI version of IYF in Daydream voice is so addictive and amazing. I don't think there's anything wrong with wanting Mariah to get her voice back in shape I just think she doesn't care anymore. I'm still listening to Caution and HFIA regularly though. NIA has become of my favorites along with "Jesus I do". (Friday 13 February 2026; 06:04) this is a reply to message 113,242

Nodules (113,242) by Stacey from USA I absolutely love the messages from HFIA, song and album. But I'd be lying to myself if I wasn't a bit conflicted when listening to these songs given her current voice. It's just not the same. I feel like such a cop out seeking AI versions of HFIA, IYF and NII using Butterfly and/or Daydream vocals, preferring to listen to those versions sometimes. At the end of the day, I can't be too sad. I have such an amazing, unmatched by anyone catalog of music to listen to. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 17:32)

TMB (113,244) by Lainsky from Philippines "Touch My Body" trended on X, celebrating its achievement of becoming Mariah Carey's 18th No. 1 hit. She looks amazing in the various live performances of this song. Back then, she was in her late 30s, but her figure was at its peak - sexy and healthy at the same time. It's clear that she embodied the song's themes and made sure her body was "worth touching". As for the track itself, I was captivated from the moment I first heard it. It doesn't feature any whistle notes or extensive belting, and it has a fun, relaxing vibe. The music video perfectly complements the song's feel. Even now, she can still perform this song beautifully, showcasing the quality of her current voice. (Friday 13 February 2026; 04:53)

Nodules (113,243) by Edward from USA I find myself doing that too. The AI version of "In Your Feelings" has some great vocal moments. It is sad but it is what it is though. I don't think anything will change. (Friday 13 February 2026; 03:31) this is a reply to message 113,242

Nodules (113,242) by Stacey from USA I absolutely love the messages from HFIA, song and album. But I'd be lying to myself if I wasn't a bit conflicted when listening to these songs given her current voice. It's just not the same. I feel like such a cop out seeking AI versions of HFIA, IYF and NII using Butterfly and/or Daydream vocals, preferring to listen to those versions sometimes. At the end of the day, I can't be too sad. I have such an amazing, unmatched by anyone catalog of music to listen to. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 17:32)

Nodules (113,242) by Stacey from USA I absolutely love the messages from HFIA, song and album. But I'd be lying to myself if I wasn't a bit conflicted when listening to these songs given her current voice. It's just not the same. I feel like such a cop out seeking AI versions of HFIA, IYF and NII using Butterfly and/or Daydream vocals, preferring to listen to those versions sometimes. At the end of the day, I can't be too sad. I have such an amazing, unmatched by anyone catalog of music to listen to. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 17:32) this is a reply to message 113,236

Nodules (113,236) by Edward from USA Smoking is a nasty habit. It's hard to quit, but it's not impossible. Dionne Warwick is 85 year smokes, I mean, old, and she still smokes. As for Mariah and her voice, it's not even 20% of what it used to be, it's sad. HFIA is definitely a strong body of work lyrically, but I keep waiting for that punch, that big vocal or emotional moment in at least a few of the songs, but it just never really comes. While I do love the album, for Mariah standards, to me, it stays flat from beginning to end. I think a lot of us still hold onto that tiny bit of hope hope that somehow her voice will turn around, but I doubt it now. At this point, I don't even know why she keeps performing, or maybe I should say lipping, because that's mostly what it is now. I can understand miming a song or two, or saving your voice for certain climactic moments, but just standing there, looking pretty and going through the motions? That doesn't do it for me. (Wednesday 11 February 2026; 19:04)

We belong together on GMA 2013 (113,241) by Giovanni from USA That's the Mariah I miss. Confident, singing live, happy and engaging with the crowd. She went off singing that song and I think that might be her best performance of the song. Oh and the hair and dress was on point. I'll never get over the disaster that was of that era. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 08:44)

Nodules (113,240) by Giovanni from USA I agree her voice was perfect and sounded so angelic that year. It seems like everything went down hill after her shoulder injury and after the divorce. One of Marian's problems is that she is surrounded by yes people and more and likely they don't care about her voice or legacy. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 07:43) this is a reply to message 113,235

Nodules (113,235) by Rashidi Rahim Rick from Malaysia If she stops drinking or smoking whatever purple taking her higher, she will gain back her voice. Remember when she was pregnant in 2010 and she performed One Child in Washington? Her tone of her voice for the first verse specifically the part "blessed baby boy" that was pure Music Box tone but the mature version. (Wednesday 11 February 2026; 14:51)

Mariah's voice (113,239) by Giovanni from USA I'm glad we're finally discussing the current state of Mariah's voice. There are many fans who are delusional and who are in denial. I really think Mariah doesn't care and has just accepted how she sounds and like Edward said it's sad. I really do like HFIA but it would be so much better and enjoyable if Mariah had her MOAIA or Caution voice. I appreciate her giving us another album but I believe there is something that happened or something that's going on and why her voice sounds the way it does. I read that medications can cause dryness and inflammation and that's what we hear. I feel so bad as I'm typing this because I feel as though I'm trashing her but I'm not. I just want her to sound good again and I refuse to believe that's not possible. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 07:37)

The prime music era (113,238) by Lainsky from Philippines I couldn't agree more. Today's music and songs often feel forgettable and lack the staying power of music from the 70s, 80s, and 90s. This also applies to the artists themselves. For example, music from the 2010s onward is rarely heard on the radio (yes, I still listen to it) or on social media platforms and apps. Although Whitney Houston, Aretha Franklin, and their contemporaries are long gone, their music continues to live on and be played. Thank God we still have Mariah Carey and Celine Dion. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 02:21) this is a reply to message 113,230

The prime music era (113,230) by Tijl from Belgium I just arrived at home and put on the old YouTube. The algoritme decided to kick off with "When You Believe". Bloody hell. What happened to music and true artistry? That song and video, uniting two of the greatest singers ever was in 1998 and yet still delivers. We might never experience this again in our lifetime and life goes on but boy, those were the days. (Tuesday 10 February 2026; 20:27)

Nodules (113,237) by Xavier mariohmix from Spain Same here. I agree with everything you said. I thought that it's been pointless to maintain this since she started to lipsynch the whole concerts for The Celebration of Mimi Vegas residency, or even the Christmas ones right before. (Thursday 12 February 2026; 02:15) this is a reply to message 113,236

Nodules (113,236) by Edward from USA Smoking is a nasty habit. It's hard to quit, but it's not impossible. Dionne Warwick is 85 year smokes, I mean, old, and she still smokes. As for Mariah and her voice, it's not even 20% of what it used to be, it's sad. HFIA is definitely a strong body of work lyrically, but I keep waiting for that punch, that big vocal or emotional moment in at least a few of the songs, but it just never really comes. While I do love the album, for Mariah standards, to me, it stays flat from beginning to end. I think a lot of us still hold onto that tiny bit of hope hope that somehow her voice will turn around, but I doubt it now. At this point, I don't even know why she keeps performing, or maybe I should say lipping, because that's mostly what it is now. I can understand miming a song or two, or saving your voice for certain climactic moments, but just standing there, looking pretty and going through the motions? That doesn't do it for me. (Wednesday 11 February 2026; 19:04)

Nodules (113,236) by Edward from USA Smoking is a nasty habit. It's hard to quit, but it's not impossible. Dionne Warwick is 85 year smokes, I mean, old, and she still smokes. As for Mariah and her voice, it's not even 20% of what it used to be, it's sad. HFIA is definitely a strong body of work lyrically, but I keep waiting for that punch, that big vocal or emotional moment in at least a few of the songs, but it just never really comes. While I do love the album, for Mariah standards, to me, it stays flat from beginning to end. I think a lot of us still hold onto that tiny bit of hope hope that somehow her voice will turn around, but I doubt it now. At this point, I don't even know why she keeps performing, or maybe I should say lipping, because that's mostly what it is now. I can understand miming a song or two, or saving your voice for certain climactic moments, but just standing there, looking pretty and going through the motions? That doesn't do it for me. (Wednesday 11 February 2026; 19:04) this is a reply to message 113,234

Nodules (113,234) by Terna from Nigeria With Whitney Houston, she also was a heavy smoker for years, that's what really did her voice in, also Dionne Warwick too smoked and Aretha Franklin and they both suffered extensively as singers from those wayward years. Aretha was able to kick the habit and came back strong with "A Rose is Still a Rose" but I don't think Dionne was able to. With Mariah Carey, it's a myriad of factors the biggest being the nodules - she already has a medical condition with the nodules, then couple that with the bad habits, vices and non discipline and you have this that we have today. It's quite unfortunate, her voice is totally shot and that's even putting it nicely. Nothing about it sounds pleasant nor fluid anymore. The new album while a solid body of work, unfortunately is marred by the vocal performances or lack thereof - hardly listenable. I only play two songs "Mi" and "Confetti and Bubbly". (Wednesday 11 February 2026; 12:13)

MORE MESSAGES