Messageboard

About Bill from the UK: I love Mariah more than you do. London Daydream Tour Attendee.

Unpopular opinions (109,674) by Bill from the UK 1. The Butterfly and Emancipation albums are good, but not great. 2. I Don't should have been on Caution. 3. The Art of Letting Go was the better album title. 4. All I Want for Christmas Is You is lyrically, musically, and compositionally the best thing she has ever done, and the best thing she will ever do. It will never be topped. 5. She needs to stop trying to chart. Those days are gone for her. 6. She looked better and came across better when under Tommy's guidance and management. (Thursday 10 July 2025; 18:14) this is a reply to message 109,657

Unpopular opinions (109,657) by Haiji from United States Regarding only songs or albums, what are some unpopular opinions you all got? "Hero" still hasn't grown on me yet. "Thank God I Found You" was not #1 worthy and based on how many song I listen to from each album, Caution is my least favorite. (Wednesday 9 July 2025; 16:34)

Album titles (109,649) by Bill from the UK Reprimand: Warranted Memoirs of an Imperfect Elusive Charmbracelet-wearing Emancipated Chanteuse Squared Merry Christmas T(h)ree (the third and final attempt to make Oh Santa happen) You Can't Spell Mariah without A and I - The Return of the Genetically Engineered Voice Glitter 2: Sylk's Revenge (Monday 7 July 2025; 21:55)

Heavy songs (109,617) by Bill from the UK Oh is Mariah a beauty school drop out? She's never mentioned it. (Saturday 5 July 2025; 01:20) this is a reply to message 109,602

Heavy songs (109,602) by Randy from USA Jaker20, I think Portrait on Caution is heavy so she'll do at least one. Languishing from Memoirs is heavy. Most of yall hate it but Memoirs to me is the closest follow up to Butterfly. I remember Mariah saying in the promos for Glitter, I'll never abandon my ballads they are a part of me. We will get something heavy on the new album. Any word on an album title yet? Dangerous? No MJ did that. Overhead Lighting? Anniversaries? Hey, it's one word. Beauty School Drop Out? The Reinterpretation of Mimi? How about, The Mimi Theorem, a2 + b2 = c2? Maybe, Mariah Nunez? Me. I'm Still Mariah. The Songbird Supreme. Ok ok I'll stop, (Friday 4 July 2025; 14:15)

One Heart, One Voice (109,579) by Bill from the UK Haha, honestly Stacey all I could do was laugh out loud. A reprimand was warranted indeed. I might add that to my bio on this site: Reprimanded in July 2025 by Lambi (warranted). (Thursday 3 July 2025; 08:31) this is a reply to message 109,575

One Heart, One Voice (109,575) by Stacey from USA A reprimand was warranted, lol. That's it Bill, you are in your room the rest of the night. No TV. (Thursday 3 July 2025; 02:26)

One Heart, One Voice (109,571) by Bill from the UK Lol. (Wednesday 2 July 2025; 19:33) this is a reply to message 109,565

One Heart, One Voice (109,565) by Lambi from USA Appreciate the mediating spirit Bobby A. You are truly a godsend. Keep it up. Everyone's allowed to have opinions of course but everyone is also responsible for their opinions. The lesson here is you can't just say ridiculous things and expect not to be called out on it. It's good to be the adult in the room to snap toddlers back to reality. Therefore members aren't just spewing disrespectful unhinged remarks like, "Her voice is so shot us board members probably sing Hero better than her now." Words have meaning and a reprimand was warranted. (Wednesday 2 July 2025; 05:44)

One Heart, One Voice (109,563) by Bill from the UK As I said before, chill out for a change. You'll notice you've made a bit of a fool of yourself as I didn't say I could, although I can sing "the way, hey" from Hero without needing backing tracks, backing singers, auto cues, lip syncing, lighting, and an army of men to navigate me across the stage. I'd direct you to this really good platform called YouTube. From there, type in the search box "Mariah Carey cover/karaoke" or words to that effect. You'll be presented with an almost inexhaustible list of unprofessional singers, amateurs, and hobbyists who can carry the tune of Hero just as well as Mariah did back in 1993. Mariah *was* one of the greatest vocalists of a generation, but sadly isn't any longer. How or why that happened will only ever be speculation because she herself will not come clean about what happened to her voice, and continues this masquerade of being this phenomenally good singer when she simply isn't any more. If you genuinely can't see that, then you are just another delusional yass queen who has no place in the fandom, as you're part of the problem as much as she is, for continuing on the facade. (Tuesday 1 July 2025; 20:49) this is a reply to message 109,552

One Heart, One Voice (109,552) by Lambi from USA That is funny. I pressed you on this before but you ran away and hibernated. Let me recap what you said, verbatim: "Mariah's voice being damaged beyond repair to the point that a number of us unprofessionals on this board can probably sing 'Hero' better than she can and with no lipping." "A number of us" so you've appointed yourself a part of some imaginary choir of amateurs who can outsing one of the most technically revered vocalists in music history. Tremendously bold claim. Since you said this your chest, you at least must be a willing representative of the group to back it up, right? So let's just hear it. Debunk my insinuation that you're out of touch. If you're confident enough to dismiss quite literally the greatest vocalist of all time, a quick vocal clip should be a walk in the park. Or are you just going to go on hibernation again? (Tuesday 1 July 2025; 06:23)

One Heart, One Voice (109,548) by Bill from the UK What on earth are you talking about? (Monday 30 June 2025; 21:46) this is a reply to message 109,530

One Heart, One Voice (109,530) by Lambi from USA Right, and people are allowed to defend their bold claims as well so where is your raw, unfiltered Hero performance? No filter, no effects. Just your voice proving us "unprofessionals" really out sing Mariah today. You talked pretty big so I was really hoping to hear your vocal cords shine. (Sunday 29 June 2025; 18:50)

One Heart, One Voice (109,525) by Bill from the UK Oh, chill out for once. People are allowed to have an opinion and express it. The song is banal and bland, and Mariah doesn't sound good. The only good thing to come out of it, for me, is that the book can now finally be closed on Mariah and Walter teaming up again. They had their day in the sun. I would take the songs on Emotions, Music Box, Daydream and Butterfly over any further paint-by-numbers triteness such as this. (Sunday 29 June 2025; 11:23) this is a reply to message 109,519

One Heart, One Voice (109,519) by Lambi from USA One, Mariah didn't write it. Two, the song is not bad considering 80% of the board here profess their liking to it, it was truly well received. Three, it's really more about Mariah being able to have a special moment with another late diva, Barbra. Aretha already passed and she never got to record anything in the studio with MC. Patricia Carey already passed and I bet you Mariah wishes she did more projects with her. With this context, it should inform you that this collaboration hold some weight for MC. Like your common sense should actually come on. And saying, "it's not a song that needed to be written" should ring to be unbelievably disrespectful and unbelievably tone-deaf. Are you just deluded with your "music taste" superiority that you thought that was okay to say? It is grandma music but like literally Barbra is nearing 90 years old. What the hell else did you expect? Also what is up with lambs being like this? "Go on and attack me." It's like they ruthlessly attack someone's artistry and then they get a warranted response and suddenly they're the ones being "attacked". The level of derangement is actually so comedic at this point. Stop gaslighting us. (Saturday 28 June 2025; 23:44)

One Heart, One Voice (109,505) by Bill from the UK I don't remember texting you Randy. I agree with you. It's okay, but it's hardly a return to the 90s and Mariah sounds the worst out of the three. (Friday 27 June 2025; 21:23) this is a reply to message 109,495

One Heart, One Voice (109,495) by Randy from USA I don't like it. Here's the thing. I knew it would be a ballad from the 90s. I knew it would feel "crowded". And I do think it's genius how he interchanged them throughout the verses. I am a Mariah Carey fan and what's most important to me is a lyric. Then the vocal. Then the arrangement. The lyrics are both banal and generic. It's not a song that needed to be written. It's been written before. I feel as though this is one of the songs sung before a Super Bowl national anthem with young girls from around the world tryna count steps with lame choreography. It belongs at the end of a really bad movie where the credits are more entertaining than the plot. My favorite person on this board woke me up out my sleep with a text for this? It's just Another Trite Hope Song rackin my brain like crazy. (Friday 27 June 2025; 16:40)

Comments (109,385) by Bill from the UK Eddie me too. I was howling at the YouTube comments where everyone's going nuts that she walked unaided up and down the runway. I'm dead. (Monday 16 June 2025; 22:36) this is a reply to message 109,359

Comments (109,359) by Edward from USA The comments are cracking me up. Many of them about the fact she walked that whole runway by herself. I love the performance, she definitely looked more alive. (Monday 16 June 2025; 03:26)

Summertime Ball (109,384) by Bill from the UK Okay so when I saw that massive runway I was fearing for my life but God bless her she managed to pull it off. So she moved and walked unaided, has finally axed that annoying "stick finger in ear and waggle head" theatric when lipping a high note, engaged with the crowd (how sweet was little Sophia), seemed present, didn't go on about the lighting, was confident, and actually gave the type of performance you'd expect from Mariah Carey. To think a few weeks back she looked like she was about to drop down dead and now here she is like she walked out of 2008. What a turnaround. I mean sure she still lipped her way through almost everything but I can forgive that due to her actually putting in some damn effort for once. Well done. (Monday 16 June 2025; 22:34)

Bill (109,343) by Bill from the UK Aww you guys stop. Thank you for the nice words and nice to see you posting again Dove. Great to see a number of OGs come back like T-Dang created some sort of seance or something. As for the video... eh. Have we really got to the point where we're suggesting they should use AI to animate Mariah? With her vocals likely being incredibly souped up as well what would be left of the Mariah of 1990? Come on. Yes she looks flawless but I stand by my lamentation from a few weeks back that something is really not right with her if she is unable to move anymore. If she came to us and said "hey lambs, I'm suffering with [insert neurological disorder] and have been since 2008" then we'd all be applauding her efforts to keep herself out there and current rather than scratching our heads. Like everyone else I have no idea who Mr Beast is. Were the other men in the video famous too? I've not really paid attention to the mainstream since like 2005 so I've no idea who anyone is. I thought Dua Lipa was that language app with the psychotic owl. (Sunday 15 June 2025; 11:53) this is a reply to message 109,329

Bill (109,329) by Dove from United States I used to come on here a looong time ago and I still think about you guys sometimes. No one posted their pictures back then so I had my own mental image of what everyone looked like. Bill was one of my favorites, but in my mind he looked like the dad from Honey, I Shrunk the Kids. So when I saw that handsome face I was just super surprised. If I was still young enough to have kids, I would totally have a kid for you Bill. Smart, funny, kind, and handsome? That’s rare. (Sunday 15 June 2025; 02:57)

Video (109,300) by Bill from the UK I hope it lives up to the hype. I remember the Crapfinity video was supposed to have "major stunts" in it. All the stunt ended up being was Mariah walking down a few steps unaided. (Saturday 14 June 2025; 18:57) this is a reply to message 109,298

Video (109,298) by Haiji from United States Better be worth it lol. (Saturday 14 June 2025; 17:57)

Thirsty (109,289) by Bill from the UK I remember ages ago I told y'all that Thirsty was written about Damizza, but got shot down saying it was about Nick. Which is stupid because Thirsty was written and recorded when they were still married. Mariah gave up on Damizza and their friendship a long time ago because he kept spewing crap and spilling secrets to get his name out there. (Saturday 14 June 2025; 12:19)

Change your type (109,235) by Bill from the UK What I don't get about the song is that she's seemingly bashing all her ex husbands and boyfriends and relenting about how awful they were, to then go on and say she's looking for somebody who's exactly that type? So she's just accepted a life a doomed romances from this point on then? Maybe go for a different type of guy if the last 20 haven't worked out. But who am I. (Thursday 12 June 2025; 08:22)

Type immature (109,184) by Bill from the UK I don't know if it's true or not, but I've heard the brand name dropping is actually sponsored. Not just on this song, but others she has recorded too. And not just Mariah, apparently several artists engage in this. I can see it being true, or else she's just bragging about her financial status. Either way, I wouldn't categorise it as a "strong pen game" song like I would Outside, Butterfly, Languishing, Petals, Close My Eyes etc. (Sunday 8 June 2025; 19:31) this is a reply to message 109,176

Type immature (109,176) by Lee from UK I actually really like the melody of Type Dangerous but the lyrics feel tired. Why is Mariah name dropping designer labels in her songs at this point in her career. To me, this is immature and lazy song writing. I hope the rest of MC16 gives us lyrics with more substance.There is no way Mariah can perform this song live, we all know she struggles with breath control and these lyrics are delivered too quickly for Mariah to perform live. The only way she'll manage it is if she has backing singers deliver every other line as in Make it Happen. (Sunday 8 June 2025; 10:23)

Tommy Motola (109,146) by Bill from the UK He's got a point to be fair. It's been almost 30 years since they separated. She's gotta shake it off. (Saturday 7 June 2025; 12:23) this is a reply to message 109,143

Tommy Motola (109,143) by Jamie from UK So yesterday I noticed Tommy was posting quite a bit on insta, I didn't think too much about it until this morning I've noticed on his story, he's put a post that says "You gotta know when to S.T.O.P." Not sure if this is a dig at Mariah or means something else? (Saturday 7 June 2025; 08:40)

Bill (109,037) by Bill from the UK (Thursday 5 June 2025; 07:01) this is a reply to message 109,003

Bill (109,003) by Edward from USA Some people seriously need to get off their high horse. Bill is an appreciated member of this board. When he stepped away for a while, a lot of us genuinely missed him. A bunch of us have been here for over a decade. We've supported Mariah through her ups and downs, bought the music, defended her when it counted, and yes, we've also kept it real when needed. We've seen plenty of people come and go, showing up with loud opinions and disappearing just as fast. Some may not like what Bill said, but no one here gets to question his or anyone else's place fandom. If for some of you the idea of being a fan means clapping for everything and pretending everything's perfect all the time, that's not what this board is about. And if hearing a different opinion is too much for you, you might want to grab a helmet, it's 2025. I've said it before: one of the reasons this board has lasted over 20 years is because it's always allowed for different opinions. Not just blind praise, but real talk too. That's what keeps it interesting. Every time this place turns into an echo chamber, it just dies out. And yeah, sometimes we get frustrated and show a little tough love. But that's only because we know what Mariah is capable of. That doesn't mean we don't love her or support her any less. I actually appreciate reading different opinions, even ones I don't agree with. That back and forth is what makes this board work. It's not a fan club where everyone's forced to say the same thing. Bill, you've been part of this board for years, and most of us really value what you bring. Don't even think about disappearing. (Tuesday 3 June 2025; 19:46)

Nasty, nasty comment (108,925) by Bill from the UK Correct, I am sad and unhappy that Mariah Carey is now nothing but a shadow of her former glorious and wonderfully captivating self. You and your kind can continue ignoring it. Perhaps I'll go back into hibernation again and pretend this isn't happening. Mariah I pray you get the help you need, God bless you always. (Saturday 31 May 2025; 14:48) this is a reply to message 108,916

Nasty, nasty comment (108,916) by David from USA "2. Alcohol is known as one of the absolute worst things for a singing voice. Mariah's voice being damaged beyond repair (to the point that a number of us unprofessionals on this board can probably sing Hero better than she can and with no lipping) suggests she has indulged too much in this vice." Another fan disparaging and mocking Mariah with one of the most offensive comments I've seen yet (the part in parentheses). I feel sorry for you, buddy - you and all the lambs on here who wile away your hours hurting the woman who profess to love must have very sad, very unhappy to have to act out in this way. (Saturday 31 May 2025; 05:16)

Mariah Carey had 50-11 nose jobs but still insecure about "bad side"? (108,908) by Bill from the UK An objective look at Mariah's behaviour leads me to think that yes, alcoholism has been massively responsible for the person we see before us today. Let's unpack it all: 1. From Butterfly references to alcohol and drinking became more prominent in her lyrics. 2. Alcohol is known as one of the absolute worst things for a singing voice. Mariah's voice being damaged beyond repair (to the point that a number of us unprofessionals on this board can probably sing Hero better than she can and with no lipping) suggests she has indulged too much in this vice. 3. Alcoholism can be inherited and she has stated that her mother suffered from this disease. 4. She has been taking medication for her bipolar since Glitter. Also since then, we have seen her on many, many occasions drinking flamboyantly and recreationally, which you should not do when taking medication. This may cause her somewhat disassociated persona of recent years. 5. She cannot walk on stage without assistance. 6. Her speech can be slurred, rambling, and nonsensical at times. 7. It was most evident during the Nightmare era. I don't think there's a picture available from that time of her not holding a glass of champagne. As I've said previously I do wish she would come clean about what she is battling. Be it alcoholism, drug dependency, a debilitating disease etc. She is clearly not right. I hate that the Yass Queens just brush it all aside. I've loved Mariah since the moment I saw her. I sometimes think I'm the only person that cares about her in this way. I don't care about number ones, sales, her being the "queen of shade", or her damn lighting. All I care about is her and her being healthy, and happy. And she is not. (Friday 30 May 2025; 18:56) this is a reply to message 108,903

Mariah Carey had 50-11 nose jobs but still insecure about "bad side"? (108,903) by Jamie from UK Do you think alcoholism is one of Mariah's issues? I know she likes a drink but never looked at it this way before. It would make sense that this is her vice and what's damaged her vocals. When I think of younger Mariah, she was so much more happier, even though she says she wasn't. You can see it on her face and hear it in both her speaking and singing voice. I just listened to Daydream from Tokyo Dome, I love when she says "thank you guys" to the fabulous four and saying "they are having church up in here" at the end of Hero. She sounds so humble and sweet, and just generally happier, a complete contrast to her personality now. I think Mariah wanted to change herself because she didn't want to be this sweet and grounded person she wanted to be more edgy, which I get, hey we would all like to be different at times but I honestly believe that's who she really is deep down and wanting to change has only led to more problems for her down the line. It's like Tommy said no one was forcing her to write those songs or be the person she was. I believe when you loose sight of who you really are and portray a different image it can only do harm to yourself. Mariah can live her life however she chooses it's not down to anyone else, that is just my gut feeling about her. (Friday 30 May 2025; 15:38)

Mariah Carey had 50-11 nose jobs but still insecure about "bad side"? (108,899) by Bill from the UK I'm surprised more people don't notice the difference from Merry Christmas to Daydream vocally. Most sight Butterfly as when he voice began to decline and change, but for me Daydream was the beginning of the end. It was just masked by good songs, good production, and confidence on the stage when performing. Main call-outs for you all to review is that her melisma became disjointed, most noticeable on songs like I Am Free. She breaks it up rather than just singing straight through the melody like she did on all her albums beforehand. Then all the body from her voice went too, best displayed by When I Saw You and Long Ago. She still sounds great but there was a very noticeable shift at this point. As this was before her alcoholism then the nose job would be the most likely cause for the change. (Friday 30 May 2025; 08:28) this is a reply to message 108,894

Mariah Carey had 50-11 nose jobs but still insecure about "bad side"? (108,894) by Jamie from UK Yes I remember reading somewhere years ago that Tommy bought her first boob job for her. How true that is I'm not sure. Sometimes I feel Mariah chose to sing differently from Daydream and that also affected the quality of her voice. But I defo agree the nose surgery didn't help. (Thursday 29 May 2025; 21:21)

Mariah Carey had 50-11 nose jobs but still insecure about "bad side"? (108,893) by Bill from the UK Mariah came to terms with her (non-existent) bad side years ago and has said as such in her interview. It is pretty clear and obvious she has had a small nose job, and a large breast job, since 1990. The nose job is incredibly subtle but clearly impacted her voice and happened during 1995. It is obvious as it was the first major change in her voice, that became more nasally and brassy on Daydream, and lost its body. That I chalk up to the nose job. The most noticeable breast augmentation was in 1999 when Rainbow launched, but there was talk of a smaller one in 1994, but not so sure about that. (Thursday 29 May 2025; 14:20) this is a reply to message 108,891

Mariah Carey had 50-11 nose jobs but still insecure about "bad side"? (108,891) by Baby from Dreamville...Where There's No Beginning & There is No End I love this theory so much and always have. Usually I'll scroll whatever site I am on and keep laughing. Today I have time: Mariah's left side is like the other side of the moon, only God and satellites have ever really had a full clear view. But we're supposed to believe she's gone under anesthesia several times and just left her "bad side" alone? Maybe the locals will humor you but a lamb will laugh behind your back. (Thursday 29 May 2025; 12:55)

She possibly had a stroke (108,823) by Bill from the UK I agree, so incredibly sad to see her like this. I wish she would tell us what was wrong. I was on edge the entire time as I genuinely thought at one point she was going to collapse. It's heart breaking. What on earth happened to her? (Thursday 22 May 2025; 23:05) this is a reply to message 108,815

She possibly had a stroke (108,815) by Jamie from UK Something isn't right. She was slurring her words, and couldn't keep up. It quite upset me to see her like this. (Thursday 22 May 2025; 10:23)

Biopic (108,756) by Bill from the UK Those that know me also know lists bring me joy. For completeness, here is the current most up to date download of reasons why Mariah can't or doesn't sing anymore. Let me know if any need adding I've forgotten. 1. Ear monitor malfunction 2. No humidifiers 3. Too cold 4. Too hot 5. Stage fright 6. Corset too tight 7. Heels too high 8. Preserving her voice 9. Scared of Michael Jackson's casket 10. Didn't want to upstage the Queen of Soul 11. Wanted to respect her peers 12. Bronchitis 13. Stressful divorce/break up 14. Arm in a sling 15. Pregnant 16. Not pregnant 17. Nodules 18. Too many splashes 19. Medicated 20. Backing singers missed their cue 21. Backing singers singing her part now baby 22. Foiled by Dick Clarke Productions 23. Late for the sound check 24. Not enough sleep 25. Too much sleep 26. Bipolar 27. Food poisoning 28. Mic wasn't turned up 29. Shit happens 30. Avoiding wrinkles (Sunday 18 May 2025; 11:15) this is a reply to message 108,749

Biopic (108,749) by Bill from the UK Avoiding wrinkles. That’s a new one for the list. (Saturday 17 May 2025; 20:54)

Biopic (108,749) by Bill from the UK Avoiding wrinkles. That’s a new one for the list. (Saturday 17 May 2025; 20:54) this is a reply to message 108,746

Biopic (108,746) by Lambi from USA Mariah's probably been heavily involved in her biopic. She's posted pictures with Lee Daniels. It's coming out some time soon. With her barely trying to be convincing when she lip syncs - it's quite obvious. She just doesn't want wrinkles to develop faster. At 56, aging has caught up with her. She's doing everything in her power to slow it down. Mariah is all about how she looks. I mean she quite literally didn't care if she was being given a tribute by Moni and Tori, it was bad lighting when Mariah was in the frame. And she will not hesitate to show her dismay. All lambs should accept that this is just who Mariah is. This is just how a beauty queen ages. She's touring and showing up and takes the time to pre-record. Nobody can say she didn't maximize her time. Musicians usually retire from performing by their 60's. We are four years away from that. So just enjoy what ever she can scramble to offer at this point. She literally devoted her whole entire life to music. (Saturday 17 May 2025; 05:24)

MORE MESSAGES