Messageboard

About Edward from USA:

The numbers are not matching up (111,695) by Edward from USA Bobby A, those are solid numbers for a legacy artist. For example, Ed Sheen's [sic] Play dropped on September 12 and opened with 71k first week sales, 51k of which were pure album sales. Yet just two weeks later, it's already out of the BB200 albums. (Saturday 4 October 2025; 03:07) this is a reply to message 111,692

The numbers are not matching up (111,692) by Bobby A from United States HFIA is projected to sell 51,000 copies for its first week and debut at number #7 on the Billboard 200. Caution sold 51,000 and had a #5 debut with less promotion and no hit singles before its release. Seems like an powerful entity has its hand in keeping HFIA's true numbers hidden and distorted. (Saturday 4 October 2025; 02:32)

"It's one of his classics" (111,694) by Edward from USA This is how part of that interview went down. Andy: Did you write it? Mariah: No, it's one of his classics, and I sang along with him and did new background vocals and did... Judging by the way she's saying, this wasn't a duet post mortem. (Saturday 4 October 2025; 02:47) this is a reply to message 111,691

"It's one of his classics" (111,691) by Lambi from USA That too but IBT is more of a ballad in her own arranged key. I feel she's talking about more of an uptempo record. Mariah said something along the lines of "I added background vocals and sang over him", and I feel I'm That Chick is closer to that. (Saturday 4 October 2025; 01:58)

Someone's Ugly Daughter (111,627) by Edward from USA Mariah is far from clueless, she knows exactly what she's doing. Do we really think Jimmy Fallon just happened to dig up an unreleased record and casually play it? Come on. That moment was clearly orchestrated. If it wasn't, you can bet Mariah would've quickly redirected the conversation back to "HFIA". She comes across as calm, self-assured, and totally in control during that interview. The promo for "HFIA" has been strong, and let's not ignore the timing, the sudden reappearance of "Someone's Ugly Daughter" on SZA and Fallon interviews is no coincidence. Something is definitely up. At this point, "HFIA" is already out, and no amount of extra promotion is going to drastically change its trajectory. The album speaks for itself, it's simply that good. Let's just sit back and relax. Mariah's cooking something, and pretty soon, we're all gonna smell what's on the stove. (Tuesday 30 September 2025; 19:30)

Lamb emergency (111,619) by Edward from USA The mike was definitely on. Simple but elegant. (Tuesday 30 September 2025; 13:23) this is a reply to message 111,612

Lamb emergency (111,612) by Bobby A from United States I thought I was going to have to call 911 when she sang the first verse live. I loved the performance. Anderson .Paak is a man in love for sure. Why do I sense MC won't let love take over? (Tuesday 30 September 2025; 11:24)

Am I "Here For It All"? (111,602) by Edward from USA I wanted to really sit with "Here For It All" before posting my thoughts, and now that I've listened to it about seven times, I can say I'm pleasantly surprised, in the best way of course. First off, the vocals. Mariah might not be belting like she did in the '90s, but she's definitely not whispering either. Her voice sounds fuller and more present, she's singing in her full voice again, and that's honestly so refreshing. The whole album gives me flashes of her early releases, and I love that. Putting "Type Dangerous" and "Sugar Sweet" in the context of the album, I'm really happy they're part of it, they both bring a nice balance to the record. And while the lyrics of "My Love" are pretty simple, Mariah's straightforward delivery is just beautiful. It reminds me of the emotion and melody she brought to her early covers, heartfelt, effortless, and deeply felt. I'm definitely loving myself some "My Love". For me, the standout track is "Nothing Is Impossible". It's honest, vulnerable, and that whistle at the end? Ethereal. Perfection. And just to clear it up: that "survived a gruesome fall" line isn't about a literal fall, it's clearly about an emotional one, which makes it even more powerful. So please, stop thinking she needs to go to the ER due to some broken bones from 2014. I was a little nervous about "Jesus I Do" before hearing it, I thought it might turn into a scream-fest, but wow wow wow, they pulled it off. Their voices blend so well together, with its catchy chorus, it is, I believe, easily one of the highlights of the album, and Jesus knows that sometimes "I Don't". Now, let's talk about the song "Here For It All." It's such a beautiful and heartfelt song. But as I said to my dear friend Randy, it would've been stronger if it had faded around the 4-minute mark. Not because what follows is bad, but because the vibe shifts so much it feels like a completely different piece that could've worked better as an interlude. I actually faded it myself at that point and it sounds amazing that way, like a perfect ending. I'm also relieved the Mariah solo version of "Sugar Sweet" didn't make it into the standard album. Just Mariah singing her parts with the chorus on repeat without Kehlani's and Shenseea's verses doesn't really work for me. If she'd sung the whole thing, including their parts, that would've been a different story and probably fantastic. And for anyone thinking this might be a farewell album, I think it's not. This feels more like liberation album. What I hear is a woman who's embraced where she is, let go of all the expectations, and is focused on the art, not the charts. It's her most honest and cohesive album in over a decade, one you can play from start to finish without skipping a track, just like the old days. Also, that chorus from "Nothing Is Impossible"? It seems to be living rent-free in my head right now. The wait was so worth it. With "Here For It All", Mariah seems to have freed herself from fear, from pressure, from the weight of "what could've been" and I love this album for that. So, I asked myself: Am I Here For It All?, and a dramatic and resounding answer came instantly: You're damn right I am. (Monday 29 September 2025; 18:39)

Article: Mariah Carey was the "worst" celebrity guest on Mafiathon 3 (111,466) by Edward from USA It was very evident that the issue wasn't Mariah. They were simply unprepared, period. The whole setup was a mess. Kai called his friends to come up, and when they showed, they looked like they'd just woken up. Total chaos. They asked Mariah to bring words for a spelling bee segment, but clearly had no plan. No structure, no flow, nothing. Kai, you had Mariah Carey on your show, not Da Brat. Next time, do your homework Mariah has been extra stiff ever since, probably from sitting in that ridiculously low, unglamorous chair. That wasn't even a proper gaming chair, it looked like a punishment. Come on. If you're going to invite a legend, treat her like one. (Thursday 25 September 2025; 17:23) this is a reply to message 111,454

Article: Mariah Carey was the "worst" celebrity guest on Mafiathon 3 (111,454) by Mimi L. from Empower Your Highlighter Yes and the whole "what did Kai get in return" thing pisses me off. If Kai was unable to negotiate what he wanted from Mariah he could have just chosen not to have her on the show. Also it's stupid to assume someone of Mariah's calibre wouldn't have a more curated image that she wants to portray. Every single thing Taylor Swift does it very curated. These people have an image to maintain. Plus she's older than them what did they expect her to do jump around? It's a shame because she really was super nice on that show and tried to be as engaged as she possibly could be. (Thursday 25 September 2025; 14:31)

Article: Mariah Carey was the "worst" celebrity guest on Mafiathon 3 (111,431) by Edward from USA Sorry, but Mariah came in with great energy and was a good sport throughout. The real issue was on Kai's side: everything felt messy and improvised. When you have a celebrity of her caliber on your show, organization is a must. I get that they're all Gen Z and maybe still figuring things out, but come on. If she was the "worst" celebrity on your show, you and your crew were the "worst" hosts. How do you bring your crew looking messy and out of it to meet the queen. Chile please. (Wednesday 24 September 2025; 19:45)

Recent falsetto (111,408) by Edward from USA I've noticed that too. Earlier in her career, Mariah's falsetto and upper register had this richness and depth that gave it a mature, almost otherworldly quality. Lately it does sound lighter, thinner, and more nasal, which can make it come across as childlike. It could be a stylistic choice, or just how her instrument has shifted over time. Either way, I think that's why those moments in "Sugar Sweet" and the live versions feel so different compared to the warmth and resonance she used to deliver. I have made my peace with all that, and to be honest, it's somewhat liberating. (Tuesday 23 September 2025; 13:32) this is a reply to message 111,407

Recent falsetto (111,407) by Lee from UK This may have already been discussed here but I haven't seen it in my search. What is up with Mariah's falsetto this era? Like on Sugar Sweet; the few lines before the chorus that begin "Hate it when you have to leave..." sound so unpleasant, especially on the pre-recorded live vocals version she used at Brighton, Sandrigham, VMA and iHeart performances. I have said this before but even on non-falsetto notes, there is something about her vowel sounds on the upper notes that sounds painful. Mariah's voice used to sound full and mature, she used to sing like a woman beyond her years with resonance, now she has gone the opposite way. There is something child-like about how she sings now and it doesn't sound as full as it once did. I'm not describing this at my best but I'm hoping there are vocalists here who understand what I'm trying to say and can hazard a technical explanation of the difference i'm hearing as a non-singer. It sounds like all the vocals are coming from her throat/nose area as opposed to her chest and when she is belting, it sounds the same just louder. (Tuesday 23 September 2025; 10:47)

Good critics for the new album (111,372) by Edward from USA There's something about "Here For It All" that just hits different. I really feel like we're in for a big surprise, but I'm keeping my expectations in check. I can't wait. (Sunday 21 September 2025; 17:39) this is a reply to message 111,367

Good critics for the new album (111,367) by MusicfanJ from Germany I was surprised to read good critics about her new album in a German online newspaper today (Welt-News) which I wanted to share with you. The critic wrote, he was able to hear the album in advance and was very pleased. It's a combination of RnB, powerballads, adult-contemporary and hip-hop influences. So everything she's known for and loved the last 35 years. He also said "Here for it all" is one of her best ballads and worth the wait. Wow, now I have high expectations. He liked the self-irony of some of her lyrics which is very rare for a non-fan too. I was almost shocked to read something so positive. So now I can't wait to hear the full album like in the good old days. (Sunday 21 September 2025; 15:51)

Rollout evaluation (111,355) by Edward from USA Randy, I'm with you on this one. The rollout has definitely been one of her stronger ones in years, and I've really enjoyed the little details. it feels like she's been more present this era. "Type Dangerous" and "Sugar Sweet" don't feel like the kind of tracks that should be leading an album, but they're not bad either. I'll give "Type Dangerous" credit for at least being different from anything she's put out before, which is a good thing. A "B" sounds fair, the effort is definitely there, but the execution could've been tighter. Hopefully the full album makes up for those choices. (Sunday 21 September 2025; 04:05) this is a reply to message 111,343

Rollout evaluation (111,343) by Randy from USA I gotta give it to MC and y'all know I don't like anything. I've enjoyed this rollout. I liked the little interviews about the album covers, her what's the next line interview previewing Mi, her going to the radio interviewers and podcasts, her talking about her videos interview, her previewing Mi with merchandise, I liked the MTV performance and the video for Type Dangerous was pretty good. I like the album artwork and the track listing. Hopefully she'll do some television this week. I have two issues. And they are major. The first is the choice of singles. Even the most die hard "yasss queen" would have to admit that you put your best foot forward when you need an album to do well. Type Dangerous and Sugar Sweet while ok songs are album tracks at best. They are not singles and that worries me for the album's quality. The second thing is that the fact that she and Gamma thought they were singles and ushered the rollout a month too early. It was delusional. If I had to grade this rollout I can't give it an A+ because of them acting from purely false hope. I would have to give it a solid B. I'm excited for Friday but very apprehensive about where this will rank as far as quality in her catalogue. (Saturday 20 September 2025; 19:49)

What's wrong with Mariah (111,282) by Edward from USA Bobby A, if you break your hip at 30, what are you supposed to do, sit around until you’re 60 to get it fixed? Please. That’s why Mariah sometimes moves a little stiff, giving robot realness. It's not her fault though, back them hip replacement technology wasn't that advanced. (Thursday 18 September 2025; 02:02) this is a reply to message 111,281

What's wrong with Mariah (111,281) by Bobby A from United States I don't think MC had hip replacement surgery at 30 years old. That type of surgery is generally for people 60 and above. (Thursday 18 September 2025; 00:50)

What's wrong with Mariah (111,274) by Edward from USA She actually ended up having hip replacement surgery. If you remember her MTV Cribs episode, she fell off a treadmill while working out in high heels. Classic Mariah. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 20:32) this is a reply to message 111,269

What's wrong with Mariah (111,269) by BFF from United States This video claims she had hip replacement surgery back in 2000? That sounds pretty outlandish - having hip replacement at the age of 30/31. What possibly could have been happening at that time to cause such a surgery? Doesn't make any sense to me. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 16:28)

Vegas residency (111,273) by Edward from USA At this point, I can appreciate some good lipping. Mariah has managed to fool me a couple of times, and honestly, I don't mind. It lets me relax instead of sitting on the edge of my seat, so I can just enjoy how great she looks and take in the whole performance. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 20:29) this is a reply to message 111,268

Vegas residency (111,268) by Jamie from UK Haha I know, imagine she comes out with full on 1994 vocals and shuts everyone up. Somehow I think we're a bit late in the day for live vocals now, which is sad but it's where we're at I guess. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 15:50)

Billboard Hot 100 (111,266) by Edward from USA I was just scrolling through the Billboard Hot 100 like I used to, and I'm flabbergasted, who are all these people? I think I only recognized about seven artists on the whole list. Times have really changed. That's why Mariah being at the top every single year with "AIWFCIY" is something we should never take for granted. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 15:38)

Curse or cuss (111,265) by Edward from USA Stacey, it's really sad. Even when we try to keep kids away from "bad words", like we used to call them, social media just blasts them from every angle. That's why the foundation they get at home is so important. Sure, they'll hear those words, but they should also know better than to actually use them. I remember when I was a kid, about 12 years ago, if I heard an adult outside my family cuss, I was shocked, I had never once heard my parents do it. Even now, I don't really cuss, though I might drop a word or two with friends, but it's not part of how I normally talk. I know it sounds harsh by today's standards, but where I grew up, if you disrespected your elders or cussed, you'd get smacked right on the mouth. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 15:12) this is a reply to message 111,250

Mariah's priorities (111,250) by Stacey from USA I am glad we have warnings. As a mom to three kids (17, 14, 12), I don't want my children thinking those words are acceptable in their daily language. Swear words lack credibility with me. Just so unnecessary, IMHO. Sure my kids are exposed to them daily in school. I teach them to avoid using those words. My hope is that they will use them sparingly like me, lol. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 01:17)

Vegas residency (111,264) by Edward from USA Jamie, you've set yourself up for a "I really hope she sings live this time, just so we can finally shut you up". I got one of those from Zachariah, and it was awesome. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 14:50) this is a reply to message 111,258

Vegas residency (111,258) by Jamie from UK Because she’s been doing it for years and more so recently. But if she sings live then bonus but highly doubt it (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 11:43)

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,259) by Edward from USA Autocorrect is killing me. Instead of "I like other artists" I meant "Unlike other artists". (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 12:19) this is a reply to message 111,251

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,251) by Edward from USA Stacey, I like other artists, Celine had a custom-built $75M, 4000-seat created just for her at Caesars Palace called The Collosseum. For years Vegas had the reputation of being where artists with fading careers went to perform, but Celine completely changed that narrative. She made performing in Vegas relevant and prestigious. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 04:11)

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,251) by Edward from USA Stacey, I like other artists, Celine had a custom-built $75M, 4000-seat created just for her at Caesars Palace called The Collosseum. For years Vegas had the reputation of being where artists with fading careers went to perform, but Celine completely changed that narrative. She made performing in Vegas relevant and prestigious. (Wednesday 17 September 2025; 04:11) this is a reply to message 111,243

Article: Mariah Carey announces Las Vegas Holiday shows (111,243) by Stacey from USA I saw Celine in Vegas in 2003. The whole idea seemed so odd. A huge artist like Celine playing Vegas? The same town that loves Wayne Newton? And yet, here we are with many artists doing the same thing years later. Celine was ahead of her time in this respect. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 17:40)

GTFO Clean (111,240) by Edward from USA Eric, thank you. I can't believe I had never listened to the clean version before. I have to admit though, it sounds pretty awful. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 16:52)

Mariah's priorities (111,238) by Edward from USA I'm very curious now. How does "GTFO" sound without the f part? I didn't even know there was such version. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 15:25) this is a reply to message 111,237

Mariah's priorities (111,237) by Stacey from USA I am well. Thanks for asking. I agree the swear word is so unnecessary. The censors here in the US are different. They may release an edited album version much like they did with Caution. I couldn't exactly listen to GTFO in my car with my kids, lol. The song HFIA is so beautiful on its own. I am fangirling over these amazing lyrics that take me back to 90s Mariah where her songwriting was so deep for such a young artist. 9 days people. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 15:06)

10 days (111,236) by Edward from USA Same sentiment here. I think that letting go of unrealistic expectations makes the experience so much better. Charts are the last thing on my mind when it comes to "HFIA", I'm just excited for the new music. The last time I felt this kind of anticipation was before E=MC² dropped. Unlike Stacey, I haven't caved in to listening to snippets, but I love reading all your thoughts about it. The anticipation is seriously killing me. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 15:03) this is a reply to message 111,234

10 days (111,234) by Bill from the UK Just 10 days until we finally get to hear new music. I don't know why but I am more excited for this album that I was for Caution and Me I Am Mariah. Something just feels different with this project. I hope there's some great moments on there. (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 14:42)

Correction (111,222) by Edward from USA I meant to say the following on the third paragraph of message (111,212): "What really gets me is when some fans infantilize a 56-year-old to avoid holding her accountable for her choices and actions. Yes, she deserves lots of compassion and people around her who actually care, real friends who'll be honest, not just hype her up or leech off her. Even fans who used to deny it can see now that something's not right." (Tuesday 16 September 2025; 01:27)

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,218) by Edward from USA The album, if structured with the songs you listed, would've done so much better. MIAM definitely had some great tracks, but it also felt a little cluttered. A few songs seemed like they were just thrown in for the sake of filling space. (Monday 15 September 2025; 21:45) this is a reply to message 111,192

I'll be listening before hearing other people's opinions (111,192) by Bill from the UK Here's my version of MIAM that I playlisted, rather than the actual album: 1. Make It Look Good 2. Beautiful 3. You Don't Know What to Do 4. You're Mine (Eternal) 5. Cry. 6. Faded 7. Dedicated 8. Almost Home 9. Mesmerised* 10. Triumphant (Get 'Em) 11. The Art of Letting Go *I know it's not strictly from the era, but I think it fits. I trimmed all the filler and weak tracks out, especially One More Try and Heavenly, as they are so Frankensteined they don't even sound like her. (Monday 15 September 2025; 09:59)

Mariah in Brazil (111,217) by Edward from USA I get what you're saying, but Mariah doesn't exactly operate on a normal timeline. If anything, she's eternally twelve, remember? (Monday 15 September 2025; 21:42) this is a reply to message 111,206

Mariah in Brazil (111,206) by MusicfanJ from Germany To be honest is mostly the best thing to do. At a certain age you should be able to speak the truth. Plus it often takes away negative critics, but if not a lot of people will be harsh and criticise even more. Mariah should be more honest at least. It's not always easy but better for the soul. I hope she gets more open about what's wrong. (Monday 15 September 2025; 16:27)

Mariah in Brazil (111,216) by Edward from USA What if her situation isn't about something out of her control, but rather something she's actually choosing to engage in? If that's the case, she'd never tell. (Monday 15 September 2025; 21:40) this is a reply to message 111,197

Mariah in Brazil (111,197) by Jamie from UK Yeah I agree Bill. I think at this point she would actually get more sympathy from the general public if she was just honest with them. So what if she’s got something, no one cares and would actually warm to her for being open and honest. (Monday 15 September 2025; 10:55)

MORE MESSAGES