Messageboard

Almost Home (37,210) by Matthew from USA I just heard the snippet and I like it. But I was wondering, why is it that Mariah's belting voice seems so screechy lately? Almost like she is on helium or like the chipmunks voice. I started to hear it on Triumphant, during the chorus you can barely make out what she is saying. I think she's saying "Can't fall down" and then she sings "Stay triumphant keep on living". But that "can't fall down" part is very screechy and not at all pleasant. And I'm kind of hearing it again on this snippet. I can't understand some of what she's saying because it is a bit screeched out. Is that just how her belting voice is now, or is it the production, or is it just my headsets? Lol. Is it just me? (Sunday 17 February 2013; 3:34)

Through The Rain remix / Almost Home (37,209) by Jimbo from UK I just heard the Almost Home snippet. It's more radio friendly then I thought it would be. Not sure I can make a proper assessment until I hear the full song, but I wish MC would use less production in her songs. Just her voice and a simple piano would be amazing. Layering is great, but I think it's been a bit overdone at this point. Does anyone else love the Through the Rain remix featuring Kelly Price? I've been having an emotionally tough time recently, and whenever I feel blue, I put this song on and it makes me feel much more positive. I love the gospel vibe. The harmonies are beautiful. Mariah and Kelly's voice blend so well. I prefer this version to the original. (Sunday 17 February 2013; 0:55)

Idol editing (37,208) by RadChad from United States It's a fact that they've edited things out. Just watch the leaked Australian adverstiment. There's much we haven't seen. (Sunday 17 February 2013; 0:01)

Almost Home (37,207) by Jamie from UK Just wow. The voice is back once again. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 23:33)

Lee from the UK (37,206) by RadChad from United States You completely misinterpreted what I was saying. First off, I wasn't saying she would have to be the only female judge in order for her personality to shine on the show. I was more so saying that the tension from the feud, editing (don't forget that), and Nicki's agenda to prove herself, hog the spotlight, and upstage Mariah, has thrown the chemistry off and as a result it appears Mariah is holding back to keep the peace. Personally, I feel Mariah's presence speaks for itself on the show, I genuinely get happy when she finally gets a chance to speak, values her opinion, and sure the contestants feel the same. Mariah Carey does not have to be extra and compete with Nicki Minaj, because she is above it and has already proven herself worthy. I'm happy she's not giving in to Nicki's theatrics. I can't fathom how a die hard Mariah fan can watch the show and not see all this. What's ridiculous is actually comparing Mariah to Nicki Minaj in a less than way. Mariah needs to grow a pair? Really? Like I said, the live shows will reveal the truth. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 23:03)

Almost Home snippet/Idol (37,205) by Randy from USA I was hoping for something without vocal layering, but it sounds very current and not a R&B or Pop ballad, which would be ignored by radio, so not bad. I can't wait to buy it. As far as Idol, as with certain live performances in the past , I see a lot of fans are rallying around Mariah and making excuses for poor performance. Let me say this: Fox paid her 18 million, so it's not logical to edit her out. It is what it is, a disappointment. The woman who uses words like euphoric, disarming and elusive in #1 pop hits should be able to give well-worded relevant criticism to newcomers after 20+ years in the industry. I love her dearly, but she's underwhelming as far as Idol goes. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 22:58)

Almost Home snippet (37,204) by Will from England I've been slayed. That's all you need to say about it. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 22:10)

Lee from UK (37,203) by Jenny from South Africa Wow "vacant useless comments"? That seems very rude and harsh. You can be honest without sounding disrespectful. Maybe you didn't mean it to be rude, but it came across that way. Just saying. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 20:38)

RadChad (37,202) by Lee from UK You said, "I do believe that if Mariah was the only female judge, her personality would shine more and her critiques would be more in-depth/get more airtime." Now if this was true, than Mariah has huge problems. Why on earth would she need to be the only female in order for her personality to shine through, that statement is bordering on ridiculous. Mariah's dullness on Idol so far and her lack of enthusiasm has nothing to do with "another female judge". Mariah would look just as uncomfortable and give the same vacant, useless comments if it was just her, Randy and Keith. If this has been caused by Nicki's presence, as you said, then she needs to get over it and grow a pair. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 18:01)

More Mariah Idol (37,201) by CDC from CA If Mariah's Idol critiques are what they appear on screen, then okay. I can understand why she can't gather herself to rave over performances that are just average. Mariah has done things with her voice that are so unbelievable that they're almost scandalous. Listening to a lot of the contestants on Idol is like watching paint dry on a wall. I have some friends who work for an entertainment news program based in Toronto, so I've heard a plethora of celebrity stories (among them Mariah at TIFF a few years ago, but I'll keep those to myself ), and apparently seniority is a huge deal in celebrity-land (even though they almost never acknowledge age as a number). It's difficult to believe that artists with 15+ careers would allow a fledgling to take over the way Nicki has. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 6:22)

Sigh of relief (37,200) by RadChad from United States It comforts my soul to know that they're still some lambs that see through the whole "Nicki is a better more eloquent judge" thing that's been playing out on here. I glad I'm not the only one that can see through all the slicing, dicing, and remixing of show; along with Nicki's motive of operation. We'll all know the truth during the live shows. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 2:11)

Almost Home (37,199) by Stella from Greece I just found out about Almost Home. Mariah singing for this big blockbuster film is so exciting and full of potential. If the song is great, it could win major awards. Imagine what it could go for her, already legendary, career. I also hope that Almost Home is the new single of her yet untitled album and that people have forgotten all about that bad song Triumphant. I can't wait to hear the new song, we are so close. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 1:53)

Will (37,198) by Ryan from the Philippines Since TEOM I also thought she had nose job, but I realized everytime she comes out without or less make up (e.g., Christmas in February, photos at home with dem babies), it's pretty the same with the nose she had before. Though I must admit it was bigger in early 90's, but we don't know. As to the photo, I think that was make up. Just my two cents. (Saturday 16 February 2013; 0:27)

Mariah's nose (37,197) by Will from England Ok, look, you all know I love Mariah. But what is up with her nose in that picture (where she is on the set of "Almost Home"), is that just bad lighting or what? It looks like Janet Jackson's nose has been placed on that photo. Compare it to the banner one, it's just become thinner, pointed and smaller. Is it just me? (Friday 15 February 2013; 23:02)

CDC (37,196) by RibbonB from USA Lol, I don't know about conspiracy, but they sure don't showcase any of MC's comments. People are nuts to think she sits in hours of auditions and try out rounds and not say anything. Maybe producers are mad that she didn't play along to the Nicki-girl beef fiasco. Mariah made it clear that that sort of crap would not happen again. But I watched the last few shows and last night Nicki made a point of jumping in when it was Mariah's turn to close out a round. Mariah already told the chick that she was so genuine and was closing out for the next group when nutty Minaj jumped in to repeat what Mariah said as if it was a new thought, by saying the singer was authentic. Duh. I'm glad MC nipped that and cut NM off. Producers created the environment we see and they are editing the show to show the conflict or shine that they want audiences to see. Many are falling for it, but not me. Nicki talks too much and not about singing, because she is not qualified. But she is doing what she can to draw attention to herself and away from contestants. Mariah wants to let the contestants shine. She's doing her thing as a professional with the goods. Nicki is a wanna be trying to justify her existence on the show. (Friday 15 February 2013; 21:13)

I have to disagree (37,195) by Deedre aka MiTodoChop @HBF from Canada I don't think it s that Nicki is more eloquent. I think it is that Nicki has decided she wants to prove her value as a judge on AI, so she chooses to speak first many times and speak often. Mariah on the other hand I can feel her holding back. If you watch AI, the camera's purposefully cut to Mariah and then cut to Nicki to show Nicki's reaction while Mariah is talking. I am not attacking Nicki. I'm just feeling strongly from Mariah that she doesn't want to argue yet when MC says anything there's a reaction from Ncki or Nicki will just start talking. Like last night for example, Mariah was still talking and Nicki started talking over her. Yet I think MC is guarded and doesn't want to rock the boat or come off like a B. IMO she's holding back quite a bit of what she might say. It's unfortunate. And again, AI is extremely edited right now and they edit too Nicki a lot from what I am seeing. (Friday 15 February 2013; 20:39)

Idol (37,194) by Licia from USA The first couple of seasons that I watched Idol, I don't recall any of the judges giving technical advice during the audition phase. Seemed like they gave more sound advice during the live shows. Why people feel she should go on this full on rant about "if you do it this or that way or sing like this" during the audition phase is beyond me. Kanye shrug. I think she's doing fine now, but during the live shows I will expect more because that's when it really counts in my opinion. (Friday 15 February 2013; 18:26)

Re: eloquence by Billy from Greece (37,193) by RadChad from United States Exactly. I agree with you 100%. You would think some are new fans that just discovered Mariah, by the things they post on here. (Friday 15 February 2013; 17:14)

Expression (37,192) by Jamie from UK I too have noticed since around 2009 that Mariah speaks slower and less articulate than she used to. She still has her eloquent moments where she expresses herself well, but she has let Nicki steal her shine. Mariah speaks the least out of all the judges and her points aren't that great. Ironic that the "untalented rapper" seems to be doing a better job than the veterans. On the bright side, I can't wait to hear Almost Home. I can tell it's gonna be something special and she looks exceptional on the set of the video. (Friday 15 February 2013; 16:54)

Mariah's justification (37,191) by RadChad from United States Judging from all the comparisons from you all, I completely understand now why Mariah was upset that she wasn't going to be the only female judge on AI and she had every right to be. And now you guys are saying Mariah isn't well spoken/eloquent on the show? It's really getting out of hand now. I'm not going to attack Nicki, because I was once a huge fan of hers, but I do believe that if Mariah was the only female judge, her personality would shine more and her critiques would be more in-depth/get more airtime. I think the tiff believe the two female judges didn't make for good television and has thrown the chemistry/comradery off. Hopefully during the live shows everything will begin to gel well. (Friday 15 February 2013; 15:33)

Eloquence (37,190) by Billy from Greece Has anyone seen any interviews by Mariah, especially from the late 1990s? Mariah is one hell of an eloquent person. Her flow of speech, vocabulary and communicative skills are more than impressive. I'll admit that the past few years she appears to have changed her approach in terms of the way she expresses herself, being more reticent, but it is undoubted that Mariah can do some serious talking if she chooses to. (Friday 15 February 2013; 10:08)

Scott and Edward (37,189) by Lee from UK I agree with you two one hundred percent. Mariah is obviously the most qualified judge in terms of experience and ability, but she lacks the ability to express herself unlike Nicki. I agree with Scott that Mariah seems to be too much in her own head, maybe over thinking her comment. I spoke here recently about Mariah being unable to complete a sentence, like she gives up half way through. I think in the Hollywood rounds Mariah found it too difficult to speak to and judge the contestants and say "No" because she is trying to spare their feelings. Nicki, on the other hand, has no problem telling the contestants exactly what was wrong with the performance or to get over themselves and stop with the pitty party. I have yet to hear Mariah give any sound advice that could help a contestant improve, but maybe she is saving it for the live shows. (Friday 15 February 2013; 9:07)

Mariah and Keith Urban (37,188) by Trish from USA I have been a country fan for a while because I enjoy meaningful lyrics that I can relate to. Keith is a fabulous guitar player, singer and song writer. I would love to hear a song written and performed by Mariah and Keith, I've been praying they become friends and make it happen. I think they would write a fabulous pop ballad together. If you aren't familiar with Keith's work, look up: "I Want to Be Your Everything", "Stupid Boy", and "Raining on Sunday". (Friday 15 February 2013; 6:30)

RibbonB (37,187) by CDC from CA I remember Keith saying that Mariah was very helpful with technicalities, that she's making sure the contestants are using their voices properly. I also remember Ryan saying that Mariah would advise contestants during auditions by singing back to them. I've seen none of this on the show. It seems like Mariah is being edited down to the tittle, unfortunately. Nigel Lithgow has been open about being partial to Nicki, so maybe it's a conspiracy? (Friday 15 February 2013; 5:26)

George from UK, respect (37,186) by Edward from USA George, nobody's siding with Nicki. I don't know Nicki's music and I don't want to know it. The only time I've heard the woman rap was on Mariah's "Up Out My Face" remix, that's it. But truth should be told, and it doesn't have anything to do with their experiences. Even though it's not the case here, but everybody knows that Beyonce is a great artist/performer, but she can't talk. It's been in the media for a long time that she talks like someone with a six grade education, but nonetheless she's a great artist. Fantasia Barrinos won American Idol, and she didn't know how to read of write. Nicki is not a singer, and she may not even be a good rapper, but she definitely expresses herself more eloquently and articulates better than Mariah. So, the ability to speak and articulate doesn't have anything to do with how great of an artist you can be. Mariah can express herself very well, I've seen it, but she does it better when she's not worrying too much about being perfect. Nicki's carefree and spontaneous, which I hate, but oh well, Mariah's the best in so many other areas. (Friday 15 February 2013; 1:45)

MORE MESSAGES