Messageboard

Respect (37,185) by George Golden from UK Nicky is trying had to outshine Mariah. What are you guys on here talking about about? Nicky is a better judge? Really? She is rude and full of herself. Who is she compared to Mariah? What experience does she have to judge singers? One album rereleased twice and she thinks she is on the same level as Mariah. Nicky feels very inferior in the presence of Mariah and she should. You so called fans of Mariah should stop taking sides with Nicky, it doesn't tell well. I know she is not perfect, but please guys, show some respect to Mariah. (Friday 15 February 2013; 1:15)

Nicki clown (37,184) by RibbonB from USA A lot of the Idol comments are about the editing. The producers barely show the other judges comments and they usually start with Nicki. Strange, because she can't sing and she focuses on everything but singing. The rediculous characters she keeps passing to the next rounds will never win and some are downright pathetic. It's unfortunate because some who can sing get dissed because of their nerves. Producers have bet on the clown, but it's not working, they have created an awkward show. (Friday 15 February 2013; 1:11)

American Idol (37,183) by Scott from USA I agree with what some people are saying in recent posts. Nicki talks more confidently and chooses her words better. It's like Mariah isn't a confident speaker or something. She doesn't know what words are coming next out of her mouth and sometimes drifts off. If anything, I believe it's a confidence thing. Is she forgetting who she is? She could be giving great advice and drawing on her experiences, but it's almost like she doesn't know what to say. She always talks well in interviews, so it's not like she can't talk well, it's just like she isn't confident/experienced as a mentor. Nicki just seems more relaxed in general, while Mariah seems a bit in her own head. Maybe she's thinking too much, I don't know what it is, but something just doesn't seem natural. She just seems to be focused on how she presents herself and I think you can very clearly tell she's very image conscious in front of the cameras. Anyway, that's just my opinion. I certainly don't think she's doing a bad job or anything, I guess some people just take on a mentor role better than others. I know I'd be a terrible mentor - I prefer to be led rather than lead. Maybe she's the same. (Thursday 14 February 2013; 23:09)

Nattalie: Nicki responses (37,181) by Edward from USA I've noticed that Nicki is more eloquent, articulate and fluent than Mariah, but Mariah is shadier though, lol. I'm happy they are concentrating more on the contestants and not their personal feuds. I have also noticed that Mariah looks kind of bloated in the face, I hope she's in great shape when they go to the live shows, because she's definitely not in her desired "Touch My Body" video shape she wants to be. I can't help but comparing her to JLo in terms of grace, style and variety on her speech delivery and personal appearance. On another note, I'm dying here of anticipation for "Almost Home". I love the fact that there hasn't been any snippet or preview out there, which builds even more anticipation. I'm also glad that it is going to be a Pop song. (Thursday 14 February 2013; 20:09)

Mariah on Idol (37,180) by Nattalie from USA Ok, this woman is killing me with her facial expressions. Like I'm cracking up over here. I still think Niki is putting out the best responses. (Thursday 14 February 2013; 8:07)

Christmas in February video (37,175) by Licia from USA This is the Mariah that I love to see. Silly, goofy, not caring about her image. Just having a good time. It was a funny joke and of course the tabloids, blogs, and magazines are going to make it into something it's not, but it's still nice to see her let loose. (Sunday 10 February 2013; 23:07)

Oz/covers (37,172) by nikki from usa Wow, a movie directed by the guy who made Xena under Disney with the colorful photographer of LB. Sounds like a visual phenom already. Has anyone else noticed that Mariah's most successful albums have all had the same cover formula? The album will only be successful if the cover follows this formula of 3 rules: 1. Mariah must be looking at the camera/her eyes must be visible, 2. her face must be at/have some sort of angle but must not have her features covered, 3. her lips must be parted but not smiling. Mariah Carey followed this formula, Emotions didn't, Music Box did, so did Merry Christmas, Daydream was artistic using cropping and light/dark to create angles that otherwise wouldn't be there. Butterfly followed, as did #1's, but Rainbow, Glitter, and CB didn't, both versions of TEOM did, E=MC2 not so much but close, and MOIA had 3 Mariah's with 2 breaking rules, and MC2Y broke all 3. Just an observation. (Thursday 7 February 2013; 4:48)

Alomst home (37,171) by Jay from USA I am really excited for this song. I can't wait to hear it. I wonder if the Letterman interview was meant for Americna Idol promo, but then they decided to push it back until this song comes out. Also, I remember reading that Mariah was doing a photo shoot (when she was wearing that black top/black long skirt/leather jacket) last week with David Lachapelle and the news release has mentioned that he's wokring with her on the video/photos for Almost Home. I am really excited for this era, almost to the point that I'm giddy. (Thursday 7 February 2013; 1:23)

Almost Home (37,170) by Caroline from USA I can't wait to hear Almost Home. I think this was such a great opportunity for M. Everyone loves Disney lol. (Wednesday 6 February 2013; 22:54)

George Golden / Almost Home (37,169) by Will from England Ask and you shall receive lol. I'm very excited by this now. The 19th couldn't come any sooner. So with Disney, IDJ and Mariah's team working out the promotional tour, surely that could only mean good things, right? (Wednesday 6 February 2013; 19:41)

Tommy Mottola (37,168) by Manny from U.S. Have you guys heard the Tommy Mottola interview on Howard Stern? It is a rare outlook on Mariah's career and their marriage. They say there are 3 sides of the story: yours, theirs, and the real story. It is intersesting to hear Tommy's point of view. He sounds so sincere when he praises her. Also you can tell he is passive-aggressive about certain aspects about their marriage. You guys need to listen to it. (Wednesday 6 February 2013; 17:26)

New music (37,167) by George Golden from UK What's up with the new record? We are not used to waiting this long for a Mariah record. I hope she delivers this time. Her last two albums have been really underwhelming. Just beacause you are on AI doesn't mean you should come out with an average sound. Now is the time to remind people why you are MC. All those rnb hip hop tracks should be discarded, we need fresh retro sonding rnb. I feel Mariah has been stuck in a hip hop rnb rot. It's time to bring back that Mariah that was all about the voice and not about the drama and skimpy outfits. Please Mariah, we need real music back. (Tuesday 5 February 2013; 12:48)

Mariah & Keith (37,166) by Rashidi Rahim Rick from Malaysia I think they both look good together on Idol. I'm watching Idol this year definitely because of both of them. Mariah is getting huge exposure right now. Looking forward to hear studio version of Bring It On Home, and Hope Street (rumoured to be her new comeback single). (Saturday 2 February 2013; 7:25)

Being on time for auditions / out and about in NYC (37,165) by Licia from USA This might be weird, but I'm really proud of Mariah for being on time for the auditions. With the exception of the last episode, she's been there. You all know she has problems with being fashionably late. Lol. As for what she had on recently in NYC, you can't make everyone happy so you might as well do what makes you happy. She could have covered everything up and people would have still found something wrong. No win situation. (Saturday 2 February 2013; 5:44)

Greatest hits (37,164) by M from USA Mariah on Idol has caused her Greatest Hits to reappear on Billboard 200 abum chart. I'm excited for the new single announcement. (Saturday 2 February 2013; 3:37)

"If you want a diva, sometimes you've gotta pay the price" (37,162) by Lee from UK Another classic Mariah quote. This one is up there with "If she called me something that begins with a 'B' and ends in an 'itch', I rebuke it." Seriously though, as much as Nicki's talking voice annoys me, she is certainly trying to be a good judge and putting in the effort. It wouldn't surprise me if she was the only one kept on for next year. I hope Mariah puts on a good show for the live rounds. On another note, as much as I love Mariah's curly hair, I think she always looks stunning with straight hair. (Friday 1 February 2013; 14:01)

We should all know (37,161) by Lee from USA Mimi doesn't give a crap about the fashionistas of the world. Life's too short to lose sleep on what some [...] or [...] thinks about your outfit. I enjoyed the warm weather, too. (Friday 1 February 2013; 1:29)

Fashion (37,160) by Stacey from USA Sometimes MC gets it so right and somedays she gets it oh so wrong. Oy, the outfit out and about in NYC is one of those misses. Yet, she hits the mark pretty good on AI so far. I just can't wait for warmer weather myself. The sun came out today for the first time in weeks and it felt so good. (Thursday 31 January 2013; 21:22)

Outfit in NYC (37,159) by Leito from USA I love you MC, but the outfit is not cute. It shows the stomach you have and it makes it look like you have no butt. I expect so much more from you. P.S. I saw the top of your Spandex showing between your breast, last night on AI. (Thursday 31 January 2013; 19:06)

Fashion (37,158) by Ray from Malaysia I love to see Mariah appearing on AI with all those colorful dresses, especially green, because she rarely wears green. I can't wait for the live shows. I can't wait for the new music. (Thursday 31 January 2013; 18:05)

Nicki vs Mariah (37,157) by Scott from USA Boring. New topic please. Ha ha. (Thursday 31 January 2013; 12:36)

Nicki (37,156) by Ryan from the Philippines I like how Nicki comments, but I'm just disgusted with the type of personality she has. Sometimes I feel like she is a stage-hugger and bossy and irritating. So, when the time the table flared up and she felt like Randy also took sides with Mimi, she just couldn't take it because it striked her ego. I hope what Mariah told her of helping the contestants instead of talking about outfits was enough to shut her up. And Mimi, I love you for throwing shades at her, whether intensionally or subconsciously lol (e.g. "we're (Mariah and contestant) both Cinderella and she (Nicki) is the evil sister" and "his hat is like from a cartoon character", then looks at Nicki and realizes the rapper is wearing a weird hat too). That I-don't-really-mean facial expression of hers. So hilarious. Lol. (Tuesday 29 January 2013; 16:42)

Edward from USA (37,155) by CDC from CA I've noticed that Nicki has appointed herself as the unofficial "head judge" as well. Maybe it's in her nature to take command over others, or maybe it's rooted from an insecurity based on the number of contestants in awe of Mariah's presence. Either way, I find her irritating. I probably wouldn't be half as annoyed if her voice wasn't so loud and strident. I can see how people find her cute, but I just don't buy into it. So, if Nicki was the problem to begin with, then Mariah should've quit, returned the $18 million and began production on that stage adaptation of her Christmas album, or written those children's books, or released that charity single, or even acted in another movie. Does anyone actually believe that scouring talent is her objective with this Idol stint? (Especially after saying for years that she could/would never judge others in this type of format?) There is success and relevancy outside the pop charts, and I'm sure there are thousands of other projects that would be more beneficial than Idol. (Sunday 27 January 2013; 1:06)

Deedre / Nicki vs. Mariah (37,154) by Stacey from USA Awww, you beat me to the "Nick" joke, lol. It's easier to type Nikki vs. Nicki with the "c". I totaly get your last post. I'm glad they blew up during the audition process and not during the lives shows. Who knows, it may happen there too, lol. Heaven knows I've got my fair share of situations I wish I could have handled differently. Randy Jackson and MC are long time friends. There is that established relationship there. RJ is an experienced judge on AI. Keith Urban is a legend amongst country loyalists. Then there is Minaj. What does she add to the group? And in that question lies why she does what she does. She feels inferior, jealous. Ever been around that person in your own personal lives that has to fight for attention? Doesn't that get annoying? When you're talking, they talk louder to be heard. Minaj is doing this job as a career advancement while MC/Randy/Urban have earned their stripes already and have nothing to prove. They genuinely care about the contestants and their futures. So Minaj constantly feels the need to put herself in the spotlight no matter the consequences. (Sunday 27 January 2013; 0:35)

Nicki (37,153) by George Golden from UK Nicki on Ai is just a joke. She acts likes she's the boss of everyone else. She is blatantly jealous of Mariah, because she knows she's not on Mariah's level. She is very disrespectfull to Mariah. I don't see why folks on this page should support Nicky at all. (Saturday 26 January 2013; 22:06)

MORE MESSAGES