Messageboard

About MusicfanJ from Germany: I'm a fan of Mariah since Daydream came out.

Best ABMB live performance (114,304) by MusicfanJ from Germany Great post Will. "Made Mariah's performances so special and personable". Yes, I see it the same way. I never needed a big show, Mariah with her smile and aura was enough. She had magic back then. She was stunning all the way, her "Mariah style" so unique and I loved it from the first time I saw her on TV. That warm smile, the eyes shining. Now she seems so sad. With "HFIA" you're right too. After reading your thoughts about the album I also think it's not an up-lifting one. It has some good songs on it. I love "My love" and "NII". Somehow it feels like "a last album". I hope there will be another album with songs and lyrics more in the style of "Butterfly". But I'm not so sure that this will happen. But perhaps Mariah will surprise us with another one. (Monday 27 July 2026; 13:49) this is a reply to message 114,300

Best ABMB live performance (114,300) by Will from England I miss Mariah just smiling naturally during her singing and having fun. Lately she's so wrapped up in not missing her cue or a lyric or not hitting a note, that she's forgotten to have fun whilst performing. This performance is carefree, has improvised moments, interactions, some funny bits, everything that made Mariah's performances so special and personable. Put this performance and then immediately play her piano led moments, and it's two different people. I agree with the other comments, that spark she had for performing has faded, whether it be through medication or otherwise. I had so much trouble connecting with HFIA, because it's overall, it is just a depressing album sonically, vocally and thematically. To me, it speaks of a woman who feels lost, in the depths of depression - a theme continued on from Portrait. It puts me into a depressive mood whenever I hear a song from it. It's a feeling I've never felt from her albums, so it's my least played. There is more power in her revealing what is wrong and owning it, rather than shutting it away (look at Celine) but ultimately it is her choice on whether or not to reveal it. She could have become a spokesperson for bipolar, to talk about it, spread awareness and understanding, hell could have even used it as a source of inspiration for songwriting (it would be the most vulnerable she would be in years ever since Petals), but instead released the information to beat Stella to it and has never spoken of it since. Again, it is her right to do so, but in not sharing it, she has become a prisoner of her own gilded cage. (Monday 27 July 2026; 01:09)

Best ABMB live performance (114,303) by MusicfanJ from Germany I agree with "everyone is responsible for their own happiness". I try to live that way. But there are a lot of people famous and normal ones who really got broke "inside" after loosing someone. I can understand it. The heart can break from suffering, the soul will follow and then the health won't be there anymore. I think the divorce from Nick, the shame with all the different baby mamas was too much for her. Plus the loss of her mother. Plus maybe other things with her health she doesn't want to speak of. I just wish she would find real happiness again. Alone or with a partner. Inner peace and health. With all her money she could take a wonderful journey to beautiful places, maybe even meet normal people who are not in the circus showbusiness. She should stay away from the "wrong" yes-people. (Monday 27 July 2026; 12:33) this is a reply to message 114,302

Best ABMB live performance (114,302) by Edward from USA Bobby A, enough with the blame game. Nobody else is responsible for your happiness. That's like parents who raise their children as an investment, expecting them to be responsible for their happiness or to support them financially when they get old. Relationships can affect someone's life, but at the end of the day, each person is responsible for their own happiness. Blaming Nick for Mariah's sadness 12 years later is a huge reach and, to me, completely ridiculous. (Monday 27 July 2026; 06:00)

Best ABMB live performance (114,298) by MusicfanJ from Germany Absolutely. I agree in everything you said. That spark is missing. With it she was the best. (Sunday 26 July 2026; 11:45) this is a reply to message 114,296

Best ABMB live performance (114,296) by Lighty from China This is the Mariah that I miss the most. She had sparkles in her eyes and passion when she's singing live on stage, and more importantly, she was focused. Compared to the most recent Underneath the Stars "performance", it's like two completely different persons. I hope she gets her energy and health back, and be able to run on stage again. (Sunday 26 July 2026; 05:36)

Madonna reached number 1 (114,297) by MusicfanJ from Germany It was because of the world cup show. Right after that she reached number one. Her gig was really short but fun to watch with the Brazilian Ronaldo and the car intro. Madonna was always Madonna plus she's really fit for her age. I'm not surprised that she's back at number one. (Sunday 26 July 2026; 11:39) this is a reply to message 114,293

Madonna reached number 1 (114,293) by Randy from USA So, if Mariah can't do it because she's a legacy artist, how did Madonna do it? So many times on here there's a barrel of excuses for MC's new music not doing well. Thoughts? (Saturday 25 July 2026; 21:02)

Soulless (114,287) by MusicfanJ from Germany Yes people are the most dangerous people. They will never "help" you. A good friend is always honest and is trying to help because he/she really cares. The same with critics. Critics can help, of course they must be fair and motivating. But if something is wrong and everyone keeps applauding and smiling (mostly fake) that's dangerous. It happend to many legends. I hope Mariah has at least one person (a grown-up) who is honest and cares for her. A real friend. Not just an employee who will say yes to everything because of the money. (Friday 24 July 2026; 21:19) this is a reply to message 114,285

Soulless (114,285) by Rashidi Rahim Rick from Malaysia Someone from her team should step up and be brave and bold in shutting off the lyrics monitor whenever Mariah is performing. Instruct her to memorize the lyrics like back in the day. This should be the cure and remedy for all her blank stare (she even didn’t blink her eyes) like she's some sort of robot or something. Take a listen to that annoying “that’s so good” from her team when Mariah just finished performing Underneath The Stars from that latest video. All the yes men yes men from her team. No one is giving her constructive criticism. (Friday 24 July 2026; 12:24)

Brian Tanaka (114,269) by MusicfanJ from Germany It is very sad. I liked Bryan Tanaka, he seemed caring and Mariah was way happier with him. I wish they were still together. Since the break-up she seems a bit lost and the sadness in her eyes is still there. I really hoped they would stay together. (Wednesday 22 July 2026; 13:50) this is a reply to message 114,268

Brian Tanaka (114,268) by nancy from Switzerland Brian was a great guy. Made Mariah feel special. According to some news he wanted to have a family with own kids. That's the reason they allegedly split up. I honestly think the reason is completely another one: He saw his career stagnating next to Mariah's, and saw that she was on a downward spiral. He decided to save himself from this disaster. Today he has other projects. But still not married and no family. Sadly at some point everybody leaves her, when there is nothing left to make profit from. (Wednesday 22 July 2026; 13:05)

Bio-pics / Judy (114,259) by MusicfanJ from Germany Since we had a little conversation about a bio-pic about Mariah with pro's and contra's, I watched "Judy" yesterday. Somehow I missed this movie, but it was so good. I couldn't see Zellweger anymore just Judy Garland. The movie was intense and some scenes were really tough because it was so sad. Just the other week I watched "Control" about Joy Division, another outstanding bio-pic which is so sad too and very hypnotic at the same time. But "Judy" got me even more. I was surprised, maybe because you could see what show-biz had done to her since she was a little girl. I will never watch "Oz" with the same feelings, I didn't know that it was so cruel behind the scenes back then. But back to the bio-pic, when they showed Judy alone in the hotel room with all the pills for sleeping and so on, I thought I hope it's not the same with Mariah. At one scene a doctor says to Miss Garland: "Please take more care of yourself." Of course it was already too late which made it so heartbreaking. The movie resonates quite long. Has anybody else seen it and liked it as a movie/bio-pic? (Tuesday 21 July 2026; 10:53)

Daydream 30 - reflections (114,236) by MusicfanJ from Germany Lol, yes. In the future, there will be a chip playing near the ear or brain at that anniversary. But I will still want a cd and will be searching everywhere for it. And maybe Mariah will be still touring with AIWFIY the extra festive world tour. (Sunday 19 July 2026; 15:41) this is a reply to message 114,234

Daydream 30 - reflections (114,234) by TJ from Norway At one point, it will be [too] late. We, the fans will be so old that we don't understand the technology anymore. (Sunday 19 July 2026; 07:14)

Interesting video (114,227) by MusicfanJ from Germany I also don't like AI videos, "songs", hosts, bands whatever at all. They are still missing a natural view and creative mind of a human being and always will. They just seem fake, it's hard to describe. They may be very "perfect" sometimes but that made them even more artificial. I watched the video and it was boring and nothing new. But the headline will generate some clicks. Let's watch the Daydream concert in NYC or Tokyo. It will never get boring to me. The live version of "Open Arms" in Rotterdam is always a highlight too. I just wish she would have relessed the whole concert. (Saturday 18 July 2026; 13:47) this is a reply to message 114,222

Interesting video (114,222) by jaker20 from US With every post you're sounding more and more clueless. I get it, I had to explain it slowly to my mom too. Now you're saying that's how the internet works, automation. Just a prior post you said he did extensive research. Make up your mind. These content are scraped online fed to AI automation ok, wrapped into AI narration and deepfake thumbnail and sensational headline ok. And yes that is literally the point, to create them with little effort. see, no buzzword. At least you agree it is automated. Just a prior post you said he went in-depth and put effort into research. People like you is why these AI content are thriving. I explained it to my mom and how it's hurting the creative industry and he got it in 5 minutes. But you're just going on contracting yourself. (Saturday 18 July 2026; 02:36)

I am free / Melt away (writing sessions) (114,212) by MusicfanJ from Germany I love "I am free" and the writing session is just wonderful. You can really hear the magic in her voice on that one. The tone, it feels like an angel singing. The "Melt away" session sounds so relaxed and soulful. I will be listening on repeat the next days for sure. Daydream forever. (Friday 17 July 2026; 15:50)

Daydream 30 (114,186) by MusicfanJ from Germany OSD had also daily radio airplay here. In my memories Daydream was bigger. But alone for "Fantasy" one Grammy would have been justified. It was the time I became a fan of Mariah so I will always say MC deserved it more at that time. But it shouldn't be for whatever reasons. For me she was the best. . (Wednesday 15 July 2026; 18:57) this is a reply to message 114,185

Daydream 30 (114,185) by Bill from the UK One Sweet Day was only a massive hit in the US. Everywhere else it was just a top ten that came and went like every other song. It meant Open Arms could be released everywhere else whilst OSD was still dragging its heels at Number One in the US. Jagged Little Pill was massive everywhere, Alanis was a fresh new talent unlike anything else at that time. She deserved to win. (Wednesday 15 July 2026; 17:17)

Daydream 30 (114,183) by MusicfanJ from Germany Yes, but MC was the ultimate female star and singer in 95/96. Her hits were played nonstop on the radio even here in Germany. The same with the videos on MTV. Sure Alanis had "Ironic" but compared to Daydream and "One sweet day" it was just a shame that Mariah didn't win at least one Grammy. It was complete unfair and I understand that she was shocked back then on her second peak of her career and fame (after Music Box). There was Mariah mania and no Grammy. On a funny side note: I didn't like Alanis and her music in 96. Because she was the complete opposite from Mariah, musicwise and everything. Lol. Nowadays it's still not "my" music but I like her. Compared to today's music I can enjoy Alanis. I liked her gig during the WorldCup. And I hope England wins today. (Wednesday 15 July 2026; 14:22) this is a reply to message 114,173

Daydream 30 (114,173) by Bill from the UK To be fair nothing was going to stand in the way of Jagged Little Pill. That album was absolutely incredible. But, MC definitely should have took home some awards in the other categories she was nominated in. (Wednesday 15 July 2026; 01:10)

"If We" (114,181) by MusicfanJ from Germany Absolutely. It was such a missed hit. I remember how I loved the song immadiately back then. It had everything. A fresh sound, the melting with Hip-Hop and RnB was perfect on this one. I can also understand that Mariah don't know her until this day. Lol I'm going to play it today on my hifi real loud. Thanks for the reminder of this great song. (Wednesday 15 July 2026; 13:52) this is a reply to message 114,166

"If We" (114,166) by Billy from Greece So, I'm playing the Glitter soundtrack at the moment and what a lost opportunity was "If We". When I first heard the album, I remember "If We" was such a revelation, such a wow moment. The melody, the way the verses were structured (especially Nate Dogg's), the way Mariah stacked her vocals, and being so current, so new yet leading the pack, if you know what I mean. How can she not not know her for the rest of her life after watching your efforts being usurped by an opportunist? I know I would. Glitter forever. (Tuesday 14 July 2026; 18:16)

"If We" (114,179) by MusicfanJ from Germany Absolutely. It was such a missed hit. I remember how I loved the song immadiately back then. It had everything. A fresh sound, the melting with Hip-Hop and RnB was perfect on this one. I can also understand that Mariah don't know her until this day. Lol I'm going to play it today on my hifi real loud. Thanks for the reminder of this great song. (Wednesday 15 July 2026; 12:15) this is a reply to message 114,166

"If We" (114,166) by Billy from Greece So, I'm playing the Glitter soundtrack at the moment and what a lost opportunity was "If We". When I first heard the album, I remember "If We" was such a revelation, such a wow moment. The melody, the way the verses were structured (especially Nate Dogg's), the way Mariah stacked her vocals, and being so current, so new yet leading the pack, if you know what I mean. How can she not not know her for the rest of her life after watching your efforts being usurped by an opportunist? I know I would. Glitter forever. (Tuesday 14 July 2026; 18:16)

Daydream 30 (114,157) by MusicfanJ from Germany If this is true, it would be fantastic. My fan heart will be celebrating. I so hope it's true. (Monday 13 July 2026; 17:16) this is a reply to message 114,154

Daydream 30 (114,154) by Zachariah from Croatia We are getting a double album - Daydream 31 and Someones Ugly Daughter and then later 25th anniversary for Glitter. (Monday 13 July 2026; 14:41)

Daydream 30 (114,143) by MusicfanJ from Germany Oh yes, me too. Daydream forever. (Sunday 12 July 2026; 15:08) this is a reply to message 114,138

Daydream 30 (114,138) by Stacey from USA Oh my gosh, I am freaking out, lol. I love the tease MC gave us. (Sunday 12 July 2026; 10:30)

The greatest female artist of all time snub (114,123) by MusicfanJ from Germany For my taste Mariah in her prime had the best/unique voice I've ever heard. It's hard to describe, but songs like "Vision of love", "Can't let go", "Without you", "Everything fades away", "My prayer" show that certain magic in her tone and melody while singing. The list goes on and on. She always makes me daydreaming with her voice. But I agree that Aretha Franklin and Billie Holiday had an impact that can hardly be beaten. When I listen to them I always think about the time the songs were recorded and it makes it even more stunning. The same with Etta James and Ella Fitzgerald, those old songs have an incredible sound, masterpieces for all the times. (Friday 10 July 2026; 10:03) this is a reply to message 114,121

The greatest female artist of all time snub (114,121) by TheButterflyReturns from United States I love Mariah, but I don't think she's the greatest of all time in terms of artistry. I'd probably say Joni Mitchell, Aretha Franklin, or Billie Holiday were the greatest in terms of influence. Commercial success is another story. And I'm sure Mariah would probably reserve the "greatest" label for Aretha Franklin. (Thursday 9 July 2026; 22:08)

Bonnie Tyler (114,122) by MusicfanJ from Germany Oh yes, thanks for correction. I was a bit confused yesterday. (Friday 10 July 2026; 09:40) this is a reply to message 114,120

Bonnie Tyler (114,120) by MusicfanJ from Germany Another legend is gone. So sad. I loved Bonnie Tyler since I was a kid. She always gave me good vibes. Her powerful voice will be missed. She was so down to earth, a wonderful warm-hearted person. I'm just listening to "I need a hero", what a sound. I will always love her music. May she rest in peace. (Webmaster: The song is called "Holding out for a hero".] (Thursday 9 July 2026; 18:03)

Bonnie Tyler (114,120) by MusicfanJ from Germany Another legend is gone. So sad. I loved Bonnie Tyler since I was a kid. She always gave me good vibes. Her powerful voice will be missed. She was so down to earth, a wonderful warm-hearted person. I'm just listening to "I need a hero", what a sound. I will always love her music. May she rest in peace. (Webmaster: The song is called "Holding out for a hero".] (Thursday 9 July 2026; 18:03)

The greatest female artist of all time snub (114,111) by MusicfanJ from Germany First it was pure envy. Because she was married to the label boss, was always looking absolutely perfect like a princess, clean image, a natural beauty with money and fame and a voice that was out of this world. It was almost too much. People are okay if a person has one "thing", but Mariah really did have everything during the 90ies until 2001. Then the image changed, in 97 there was the new Mariah, most people still liked the sexy "new" Mariah with more RnB and Hip Hop influences because there were still the ballads and her looks were still great. But the last 10 years, the image went down sadly. Most people just see a diva nowadays, who always cares about her looks and expensive things but not about the music. The diva thing overshadowed the music. Celine and Adele are also "divas" but when they talk they seem more down to earth. I just say it seems so for the average people who don't know much about Mariah. I think no one has a problem that Mariah mixed the genres, at least I've never heard it. Mariah is the Queen of Pop-Soul, but yes she can sing everything. Some other thoughts why she doesn't get more recognition nowadays? (Tuesday 7 July 2026; 14:49) this is a reply to message 114,109

The greatest female artist of all time snub (114,109) by Bobby A from United States Why doesn't the music industry recognize MC more as the greatest female artist of all time? We all know that she has definitely earned the title. I think the music industry doesn't want to recognize her as the versatile artist that she is because it would cause an uproar among Whitney Houston's fanbase and stir up the whole debate of MC being the female artist who started the trend of merging pop, R&B and hip hop together. (Tuesday 7 July 2026; 03:50)

MC's best bridge (114,110) by MusicfanJ from Germany One of the best for sure. Here's another favourite: And I will breathe for you each day Comfort you through all the pain Gently kiss your fears away, mmm You can turn to me and cry Always understand that I Give you all I am inside (Tuesday 7 July 2026; 14:24) this is a reply to message 114,102

MC's best bridge (114,102) by Edward from USA I can't pretend these tears Aren't overflowing steadily I can't prevent this hurt from almost overtaking me But I will stand and say goodbye For you'll never be mine Until you know the way it feels to fly Honorable mention And it's hard And it's hard And it's hard (Sunday 5 July 2026; 05:44)

MC's best bridge (114,104) by MusicfanJ from Germany Don't say, "She takes it all for granted" I'm well aware of all I have Don't think that I am disenchanted Please understand (Sunday 5 July 2026; 12:14) this is a reply to message 114,099

MC's best bridge (114,099) by Sasha from Nomansland Reaching out into the distance Searching for spirits of the past Just a trace of your existence to grasp This song is one of the most beautiful she has ever written. So deep and hunting. I can't believe she was only 19 or 20 years old when she wrote it. Those were the days. (Saturday 4 July 2026; 19:16)

MC's best bridge (114,103) by MusicfanJ from Germany I'm addicted to the bridge of "All I ever wanted". I often repeat it while listening. Her bridges are the best. You allready mentioned so many good ones. Here's another one. You were the only one (only one) That I allowed inside my heart Now I'm just holding on To something so far gone Oh, where did I go wrong? (Sunday 5 July 2026; 12:04) this is a reply to message 114,101

MC's best bridge (114,101) by Lainsky from Philippines I love this bridge too, as well as All I've Ever Wanted. I sang these bridges more than the chorus back in the day. (Sunday 5 July 2026; 05:33)

Michael (114,066) by MusicfanJ from Germany I still have to watch the Michael movie in cinema too. Last time I went there, I choose Mando and Grogu. Lol. But I love Michael's music since I was a kid, he was the first artist I had a poster on my wall. But to be honest I'm not so interested in a bio-pic for Mariah. I fear it would be Glitter part two. I would prefer new music, a jazz album or the Rarities 2 for the next "project". (Tuesday 30 June 2026; 11:46) this is a reply to message 114,064

Michael (114,064) by Lainsky from Philippines Because of these reviews, I might give myself some time to check out this MJ biopic. And since you mentioned a Mariah biopic, who would be the best singer-actress to play this epic role? It has become a tradition for them to do only movies like this when the artist is gone. However, it would be nice to make a movie while the person being honored is still here, right? (Tuesday 30 June 2026; 05:49)

Taylor Swift (114,046) by MusicfanJ from Germany In the 80ies or 90ies Taylor Swift wouldn't have been so big and popular like nowadays. She's just there in the right time with a good management and clever business choices. Plus there's not so much competition. In the 90ies with Whintey, Céline, Mariah even Madonna, today who is there, really? Taylor Swift started as a country girl and hit the "zeitgeist" with her pop songs. She also seems nice and smart. But she will never be in the league of a "Mariah Carey". Never ever. I'm not worried at all. (Saturday 27 June 2026; 16:34) this is a reply to message 114,043

Taylor Swift (114,043) by Lainsky from Philippines Honestly, I was bothered for all the reasons you mentioned and felt disappointed when I saw that Taylor Swift earned her 15th No. 1 song, especially since it was a soundtrack. That added to my dismay. When You Believe, Lead The Way, hello? They deserved to hit the top spot and stayed there for several weeks, hello? What's happening there? I chose not to post about it here, perhaps because I'm currently in a place of contentment and joy with all the achievements Mariah Carey has made. Yet, I still secretly hope for more, such as scoring another No. 1 song and album. The points you raised are valid and make sense, but there are other reasons to consider as well. While it's true that the records she set might eventually be broken, that doesn't erase them. They are etched in history, having made a significant impact. However, I also recognize that feeling of not wanting her records to be broken. I felt this first with Rihanna, but with Taylor, she shows no signs of slowing down, so it's quite possible she will continue to break records. Given her consistent popularity after nearly two decades, I can't help but entertain the rumor that she made a pact with Satan or some cult to maintain her fame. (Saturday 27 June 2026; 06:14)

MORE MESSAGES